CENTER FOR ARTISTIC ACTIVISM — CREATIVE COMMONS BY-NC-SA

Artistic Activism Blog

Hide Filter
Show Filter

The 5 Moral Foundations

Created: 17 Aug 2017

The 5 Moral Foundations Social and cultural psychologists have identified these “innate and universally available psychological systems [as]

Creative Mapping Exercise

Created: 17 Aug 2017

Creative Mapping Excerpted from the upcoming book How To Win: The Art of Activism by Stephen Duncombe and ...

Ideas To Action Exercise

Created: 17 Aug 2017

Ideas to Action People move through multiple stages when changing their behavior. We’ll practice developing tactics to address

Imagining Utopia

Created: 10 Aug 2017

In order to change the world we live in we need to be able to imagine the world ...

ÆFFICACY

Created: 28 Apr 2017

Effect (v.) “To bring about (an event, a result); to accomplish (an intention, a desire).”
Affect (v.) “To have an effect on the mind or feelings of (a person); to impress or influence emotionally; to move, touch.” (Oxford English Dictionary)

When it comes to bringing about social change, effect and affect are intertwined. Artistic activism aims to bring about demonstrable change through moving people viscerally and emotionally. We might think of this as: Affective Effect. Or, if you prefer: Effective Affect. Or, as we’ve come to call it: Æffect.

At the C4AA we are very, very interested in æffect. Artistic activism might be fun, creative and cutting edge but if it doesn’t deliver the goods in helping to transform the world, then what good is it?

Since we began the C4AA we’ve been asking the questions: Does it work? How do we know? And what does “working” even mean when we combine the arts and activism?

Our first, and ongoing, project was to interview artistic activists and activist artists about how they thought about æfficacy in their own work. You can read some of these interviews here. Over the coming year we will be undertaking more interviews in Madrid, Berlin and Buenos Aires with the help of three “Global Fellows” from NYU’s Urban Democracy Lab.

Currently, we are engaged in a large research project studying the question of æfficacy in artistic activism. Working with George Perlov, a former VP of Research for the Ad Council, and funded by Open Societies and Compton foundations, we are undertaking a review of the literature on the topic, interviewing practitioners in the field, and developing tools for both artistic activists and those who want to support them so they might better understand the practice and gauge success in appropriate ways. You can read more about this research project here.

In the works is a multi-country research project on New Civic Action with colleagues from Roskilde University in Denmark. Among other things, we plan on staging “real world” experiments to help determine what practices of artistic activism are most æffective for what ends.


AXES OF ART AND ACTIVISM

Created: 28 Apr 2017

The terrain of artistic activism and activist art is vast, and there is no one coordinate of success. In order to map some of this landscape we’ve created the following axes where one might situate particular practices and thereby better determine relative success. A work-in-progress.

 

Risë Wilson, George Perlov, Steve Lambert, Stephen Duncombe
Rauschenberg Foundation, 12 February 2016

With an assist from Brett Cook, 1 October, 2016, British Council Artists’ Assembly


REPORT ON INTERVIEWS WITH TRAINERS & FIELD-DEFINING ORGANIZATIONS

Created: 28 Apr 2017

Download: Report on Interviews with TrainersField-Defining Organizations March 2017

Background

Following the development of a literature review last year on measuring the impact of artistic/creative activism, The Center for Artistic Activism (C4AA), conducted interviews with artistic activism trainers and other “field-defining” organizations to expand the learning for this part of the Æfficacy project. This project has been underwritten by the Compton and Open Society Foundations.

Objectives

The objectives for this research were to:

  • Build on the learning from the literature review
  • Understand the challenges and opportunities to developing a culture of measuring impact in the field
  • Learn what tools and techniques for assessment are currently being used in the field (or not) and how effective they are
  • Identify potential tools that would be helpful to the field and what needs to be done to develop them

Methodology

George Perlov Consulting conducted twelve phone/Skype interviews with a mix of artist/practitioner/trainers from field–defining organizations. Individuals were selected by C4AA for their diverse views, experience and range of work. Interviews lasted approximately 45 minutes. A copy of the discussion guide is included at the end of the report. Interviewees who graciously shared their time with us included:

  • Andrew Boyd, Beautiful Trouble
  • Nadine Block, Beautiful Trouble
  • Beka Economopoulos, Not an Alternative
  • Jessica George, Revolutions Per Minute
  • Gan Golan, Beautiful Trouble
  • Adam Horowitz, US Department of Arts and Culture
  • Andy Hsiao, Culture Strike
  • Jason Jones, Not an Alternative
  • Terry Marshall, Intelligent Mischief
  • Bill Moyer, Backbone Campaign
  • Leo Martin Saura, En Medio
  • Jacques Servin, Yes Men
  • Igor Vamos, Yes Men

Caveat

Qualitative research, such as these interviews conducted, can provide a broad view of the opinions of a small number of participants. The value of this type of inquiry lies in revealing the range of opinions held and the intensity with which some participants hold those opinions. Data should not be used to project to a larger population or other audiences. Some verbatim quotes have been gently edited for clarity.

Executive Summary

As part of its exploration of the “aefficacy” of artistic or creative activism projects, the Center for Artistic Activism (C4AA) and George Perlov Consulting conducted a series of interviews with 13 artist/practitioner/trainers from field–defining organizations. The purpose of the research was to build on learning from the previously conducted literature review and to identify what tools and information activists, artists, trainers, funders and others in the field need to be more successful in these endeavors. Overall, interviewees provided a wide range of beliefs, attitudes and practices. They also confirmed our hypothesis that more tools and resources to help plan and measure impact of interventions would be beneficial to the field.

There was little consensus among those interviewed on the idea of a standard theory-of-change or framework behind artistic activism efforts. Some believe that they should be identical to advocacy or organizing frameworks. Others believe that they need to be different due to the artistic or creative elements employed. New ideas and models based on existing models seem to be developing in the field. Challenges in setting realistic goals for efforts also add to the difficulty of planning initiatives strategically.

How impact is defined was also an area of conflicting views. Some participants saw the legislative or policy goal to be changed as the ultimate definition of impact. Yet others could see impact in more ancillary effects like reaching new audiences or media coverage of the issue. There was also some debate over whether impact could or should be a defining metric for this kind of work, and how a focus on impact might stifle the creative process or not be reflective of the non-linear nature of social change.

Trainers who specialize in helping groups or organizations use artistic or creative elements in their activism report they sometimes get feedback on their trainings from the trainees. But they often do not stay engaged with them long enough to get reports back on the impact of their work or have time to help them plan for assessment or evaluation. There is an overall sense in the field that more focus is being placed on assessment and evaluation, some of this coming from a self-induced desire for improvement, others feel it is being imposed by those who see nonprofit program evaluation as a gold standard that should be utilized by artistic activists as well.

There is a broad range of thinking about metrics for measuring the impact of interventions. Process metrics are an area that many feel are critically important but often overlooked, possibly because they are believed to be hard to measure. Similarly, metrics to help measure cultural change are greatly welcomed by the field. Media metrics, especially social media metrics, are seen by many as providing a fantastic wealth of information, but few expressed having the competency or time to plan and assess them. There are also concerns that while media buzz for initiatives is critically important in our hyper-connected world, the metrics were becoming more of an end than a means.

A few participants reported utilizing or considering to utilize assessment methods from similar fields that promote behavior change, like social marketing and public relations. The language surrounding impact measurement – evaluation, assessment, metrics, etc., — also feels foreign or alienating to many in the field.

Most report not incorporating evaluation or assessment into their projects due to lack of money, time and knowledge, as well as a focus on up-front strategy and not back-end results. Lastly, there is interest in simple tools that could be utilized without need for too much training. Those that combine objective (metrics) and subjective (story) outcomes are of most interest.

Key Findings

  1. No standardized thinking about theory-of-change.

When asked if their work followed a specific theory-of-change or logic model, participants expressed a range of thoughts and ideas. Some could point to specific models that have been used by grassroots organizers for years, others reported that they don’t rely on them and felt that they were creating models as they went along. Some viewed artistic activism as a subset of community-based activism and organizing. And some, reflecting the sometime contrasting natures of creating art and behavioral change, felt pigeonholed into using models imposed on them by others.

Overall, there appears to be a nascent “mashup” trend regarding theory-of-change — practitioners building from existing stories and actions by noticing what’s emerging, amplifying those existing narratives through symbolic actions and storytelling to make them more legible, and spreading those shifted narratives to change collective mindsets.

There is no model where it’s modeled in that way. I think there are a few indirect processes. One is the method between the local and national to sort of stir it up with local grassroots organizing conversations, seeing what’s emerging across the many sites, and then collating that into kind of a national dialogue…So the feedback mechanism of that accord is the local and national…We’re drawing from a longer history of community arts organizing or community culture, and then we draw out the body of knowledge and practitioners who have been in the field for quite a long time.

The Beautiful Trouble book has a strong framework and through lines and multiple threads of tradition in there. I would say my big influences historically would be…Abbie Hoffman, the Greenpeace media stunts…the fierceness and radical messaging… ACT Up, Gran Fury. Barbara Kruger type of messaging. And then, just a lot you learn along the way because every generation reinvents the stuff, so I learned a lot from colleagues all along the way. I would say those were in terms of the cultural practice those would be…and Madison Avenue, to be honest… I came up in the first antinuclear movement, so the early ‘80s, and that was very influenced by sort of the Seabrook Affinity Group, which created a direct-action kind of model.

And in terms of our theory of practice, or theory of change, part of it is that we need to build power in an era of communicative capitalism and fragmentation. The left has historically been allergic to power, had a very fraught relationship to it, so how can we occupy existing infrastructures and do it not as branding from above or coalition politics where we have to sit on a conference call and agree on what the fuck we’re doing. But rather look at what’s happening within movements. What are the songs, the stories, the memes, the hashtags, the aesthetics, etc., that are being used, and how can we help to make that more legible and can teach us and signal a counter power?

One thing that is very important to us is about building from what already exists rather than creating something new… which includes showing people what they’re doing, the value, and making connections between groups that are already doing things rather than creating new groups. And so, in this sense, we resist a lot of the artisans, the individualistic, artistic production or even “creativity” as a term. Rather, we point to existing forms, existing groups, who have creativity already built into their practice that wouldn’t be recognized by artists who were looking for something much more individualistic, and the thing that stands out from the crowd. We seek to not stand out from the crowd, but to create a crowd based on collectivity… So, it’s basically union organizing. You go inside the sector, like you want to enter a factory. You get a job at the factory as a labor organizer and you organize the workers on the inside. That’s exactly what we’re doing. And we speak about it in those terms so it’s recognizable to those union groups.

If we bring the right constellation of scientists and activists and museum people together, the museum sector is going to respond positively and we’ll get enough signatures that there will be enough attention on us, and the museum sector will then embrace us. Our measure of success is not just that we get the signatures, but then we can make the next move because the museum sector has accepted us as a museum.

I personally kind of despise the whole theory of change rhetoric. We’ve certainly written plenty of versions of our theory of change in different grant proposals when we needed to have one. What we try to do is symbolic action in the service of social movements because we do think that social movements succeed. Historically they do. We usually try to think of what we’re doing with the existing campaigns that are part of movements… what we’re trying to do is model our behavior after successful symbolic actions that happened in the past and that were clearly part of the collective consciousness when it comes to the success of the movement, like the Salt March, which has a sort of narrative and mediagenic element that got retold and became a part of the legacy of that movement. I don’t know if anybody ever assessed how that was successful or not. I think in the context of the movement, I think it’s generally seen as a success. But whether it actually did anything is, I don’t know, maybe you’ll be able to see now.

Our main theory is that culture shifting is the most valuable and important thing to transforming… socially transforming the world. The culture is the glue between everything else…shift culture, which is shifting people’s behavior in practice and mindset…shifting the social norms. We like using narrative and design… stories and aesthetics…How do you make things appealing and pleasing to people that creates an effect, and then what stories they need to develop…people’s stories develop to make sense of the world. You have to change people’s stories. That’s what we do.

We live in democracies. The way to change is through mass attention to things. One avenue to that is through the mainstream media. We basically hop on issues that have a certain momentum and we just try to add some more attention to it. Where journalists are already primed to consider an issue, we can sometimes come up with a funny action that then the journalist can relate in a different way than they usually report on the issue…The more people are outraged and the more people take action of various sorts, the more likely things are going to change. When you have a large number of people, percentage-wise a very small part of the population, but in numbers, large, thousands and thousands of people, when you have them taking concerted radical action, it usually has a big effect.

  1. Goal setting is a moving target

One challenge that activist/trainers find is around setting goals, as issues and problems change and evolve. Setting goals with client organizations also can be challenging as the desire for change may not be clearly articulated by these organizations, and they may not realize how long it takes to effect long-term change. Conversely, when goals are narrowly defined, there is more opportunity for success. There are also issues when seemingly good ideas are developed into interventions only to later be recognized as non-strategic. Although seemingly simple, aligning strategies and tactics with goals can be a challenge for the field.

Right now, there’s a big deal in the northeast where so many pipeline projects have been postponed or cancelled. Our activists have been fighting really hard, but they don’t really know if their fighting is making a difference, because it’s also coming at a time when all choices are collapsed, and companies aren’t finding the financing for these pipeline projects, and the fossil fuel infrastructure.

What is your goal? Are you trying to uplift people? Are you trying to shock people? Are you trying to educate? Are you doing this because you want to give your membership a chance to experiment with self-organization and creating a small project that will be part of a bigger whole so that they feel they’re part of the bigger whole? What is the actual strategic goal or bottom line objective of this? Is it just to beautify street corners? That’s fine. Is it because you’re really angry and you just need to yell at someone? Also, fine. Let’s be clear about what their goal is, and that is definitely a process, whether they bring me on to help coordinate a bunch of artistic stuff for a particular mobilization, or whether they bring me on to run a training, or to integrate culture into a conference. So, I can help them identify those goals.

There are exercises (for setting goals). We actually use the Steves’ (Center for Artistic Activism’s) visioning utopia exercise. But other exercises as well, like the magic newspaper headlines that you might want to see, and so on.

It’s like with all the different elements to the movement or people who are taking up that case, how do you tease out which parts are having what affects. Obviously, if we knew that it would allow us to better strategize and better focus and better train and better fund.

Our goals are narrowly defined as getting as much attention as possible. And so, what we do is typically seen as wildly successful for these organizations. You know, they’ll say things like we haven’t gotten a single bit of coverage in the mainstream press until we did this.

Activists make such basic simple errors. Like we’ll come up with some kind of an action where – hey, let’s do this die-in during the protest blah, blah, blah. We’ll have these puppets that represent good and bad; we’ll have this little skit going on. And it’s all very beautiful and exciting and full of puppets and music and so on, but then nobody actually bothers to step back and go, and who’s going to see this? And what are they going to think when they see it? And how is it going to work, you know?

I think the biggest challenge is the tensions between short-term and long-term, and so cultural strategies are really long-term strategies.

  1. The concept of impact is broadly and diversely defined

When asked how they defined impact of their work, participants expressed a range of thinking. For some, it was clearly and succinctly linked with the legislative or advocacy goal they were hoping to change. Others viewed their impact in various ways, like more/different stories told, new audiences engaged, communities built, advocates inspired, stories in the media, funds raised for organizations, building power, creating social cohesion, etc. Some were skeptical of being able to measure impact at all, which may reflect their own lack of skill or competence in this area.

For us, it’s the widest array of whoever we’re able to bring together. I just received a call from our agent yesterday and could not believe the diversity of who they were able to bring together.

A lot is going on. We’re not exactly sure how to measure it.

It’s very hard to really put a finger on it. The Billionaires are using a very engaging, cultural, sort of meme-based, humor-based, approach. Catching a lot of attention and interest and even joy and a little bit of mayhem that breaks out of the usual sort of narrow messaging. It’s not so much in the primary stated purpose of the organization, which might be to persuade voters, but in all of the secondary aspects …inspiring the troops, if you will, like giving people something to point to, changing the conversation, adding a meme that journalists can play off of, giving the rest of us who are doing the door knocking and phone calling work, something to feel fierce about and feel like we’re pulling a David and Goliath move when a prank goes off well, like giving us more…in the ether, in the sort of culture suit, talking points.

And then I think the last sort of measure of success is yeah, things should change. We’ve gotten eight institutions in the last year or two who cut ties to fossil fuel interests by either divesting from fossil fuels, dropping a board member from the industry, or canceling a sponsorship contract with a fossil fuel company. Those are traditional activist metrics for success.

I really think when you talk about artistic activism – that artistic activism is the nexus between creating meaning and building power. These two very different practices that, when they intercept, can become very powerful. And it’s really about channeling collective energy on a massive level, which is different than some of the individualized ways of personal transformation, or shifting someone’s opinion, or all of those things which we sometimes try to look for impact.

One (type of impact) is that it reaches audiences – stories reach audiences that might get to know about an issue that they otherwise wouldn’t be thinking about it. And the other primary impact for us is that people in the movement are energized by being in a story that is basically fun for them to read. It’s like cheerleading…I think a lot of what we do is about, at least for the younger people, is about overcoming the fear that they have of acting, of doing things. At least that’s what we get in informal reporting. Most of our methods are like anecdotal and informal, and people will write us emails saying, “Wow, I saw your movie in high school and it totally opened my eyes and now I’m out protesting.”

We did one project with this group called the Action Traction, where we impersonated the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and announced that they were changing their position on climate legislation. And two weeks later they actually did. So that’s an example of feeling like the project was successful. It’s not a causal relationship – we didn’t call them to do it –we played a prank. There was a lot of activist pressure that we were a part of, that played a role in them changing their position.

I would say that their money raised is a particular quantitative tool we use. We work with nonprofits to have more of a qualitative approach to judging the impact. After between five and eight months we go back to the organization and talk to them about how our intervention helped and we can look at social media impact…how have things changed in terms of your social media followers, have you recruited new members. We’ll ask them to help us to understand how the partnership impacted their work because ultimately our goal is to impact a particular piece of work and support an organization to reach more people and make more change.

[On the impact of one of their actions] So it’s not stopping yet, but for some, it brought about a change in people’s minds. It’s like, “Oh, I’m not alone in this…thousands of people are suffering the same as me. That means that maybe it’s not only my problem…” that created a big debate and it still is a big debate in Spain.

We have no idea how to measure our impact. It’s purely guesswork. When I see organizations that we’ve worked with talking about measuring impact, I’m not sure they do a good job at all. I think they’re just convincing themselves of things.

  1. Some questions raised about whether measurement and evaluation is needed for artistic activism projects

A number of the activists/trainers interviewed expressed concerns about whether artistic activism interventions can or even should be subject to any sort of post-analysis as to effect. These opinions recognize the difficulty of this work and in some cases, make the argument that artistic interventions should be exempt from any analysis because of beliefs that social change does not happen in linear, measurable ways. There is also a worry that measurement and criteria of evaluation can get in the way of imagining and experimenting with seemingly impossible goals and outcomes, especially during the formative stages of interventions . An underlying resentment towards funders or others who require such data or information was clearly perceived.

It’s too difficult to get meaningful data. It wouldn’t be “needed” because we actually can’t do it in a meaningful way. The second thing is even if we could do it in a meaningful way it’s possible that the practitioners are just not going to be inspired by it. That’s just not how they operate… there’s an ideological resistance to being so instrumental or even if they’re open to it intellectually or ideologically there is no mechanism for them to actually be guided by it. I am not saying “artists just do it…go off half-cocked and follow your visions.” Artists can be extremely strategic… Some of the more anarchist street theater Bread and Puppet types are not going to care about that or be influenced by it or feel that it’s a betrayal of their pureness of mission and purpose. Others who tend towards more of the deliberate campaigning with a mission and focused targets and things like that would be more so…There are best practices independent of hard numbers that I think people just know and understand through winning and losing enough times. That’s where I think Beautiful Trouble comes in. It’s not really metrics in the normal sense of the term.

I do think it matters that it works. I think artists are often accused of doing things that don’t matter because they are intuitively doing things that are meaningful and make sense to them. Sometimes they may be plugging into something that is incredibly powerful and important. So, I would encourage people to keep doing things that don’t matter to others the way that we define them, because we’re reaching out into that dark, undefinable place in which so much of human experience actually happens.

We’re creating stories that use the media as a vehicle to get them out there and to make them stick with audiences. And I think it’s really hard to assess the impact of stories. I feel for you, because it seems like a really difficult thing to do. It’s typical that we have to write reports where we validate our actions, and where we have to try to make the organization that funded us feel like their money was well-spent.

I think sometimes it’s just really obvious what to do, and those are the moments when it really does no good to think about measurements of impact. It can actually get in the way. Take the Freedom Riders, as an example. When they set off to do what they were doing, they were counseled not to do it. And the impact was evaluated by many groups along the way and they said, “don’t do it, don’t do it. Stop, this is backfiring.” It went all the way to the White House, and the White House was calling these people and saying don’t do this. Martin Luther King was against it. Everybody was against it. And yet, in retrospect, it’s clear it was a massive triumph and moved the whole civil rights movement forward in a really dramatic way, including moving Martin Luther King’s organization forward.

Change happens, some things happen in very unexpected ways that nobody predicts. I really don’t think that I want to waste any of my time trying to figure out what’s going to have the biggest impact, because I’m pretty sure I don’t know…I think that might be the biggest flaw in the impact assessment model. It supposes that people are going to do something different from what they want to do based on some mysterious number magic… (on Occupy Wall Street) I don’t think very many of them realized what would happen or how it would work out. So, I don’t think it would have helped for people to be thinking about that at the beginning. Even if you have a perfect model for the whole thing, I don’t think it would have changed anything.

  1. Evaluation as part of training and strategy development

Whether training others or developing their own work, evaluation is not often an up-front consideration. Some who work with organizations in the up-front planning and strategic stages found they did not have the opportunity to follow through with these groups regarding impact. Or not think about impact until later in the process. Some did utilize process evaluation tools to get feedback and learning along the way in their trainings.

We are not as strong on inventorying the impact of our work and when we do our strategic planning trainings and work with groups we train around the importance of ongoing assessment. We’ve been doing more trainings…we haven’t had long-term campaign clients where we needed to do that…I don’t think we emphasize (evaluation) because we join groups more at the frontend than at the backend…We’re the creative people they pull in more when they’re planning or thinking or brainstorming. That’s where we can intervene with good strategic planning, which is more on the tactic side of things rather than evaluation, assessment, et cetera. We do emphasize the importance of evaluation, and that it needs to be built into their plan, and that you need to allocate resources, and that it should not be just something that happens at the very end but is used as a constant course correction. I would again say that we’re probably weak on the quantifying of that.

We just throw our energy behind stuff and then along the way or after the facts we measure. But we’re trying to get better about that now.

At the end of every training, or if it’s a multi-day training we integrate it in different ways – we do things that we call cute little names like check-ins or debriefs or use tools called head-heart-hands, or thorns-and-buds, or whatever, to try to assess what people are taking away from it. So, on a very small, local level, we do evaluation. Sometimes, not every time because of time constraints and because it’s not a priority for people, we do written evaluation and we collect them.

When we finish the product or training, that’s when we can say our job is done…we completed that, that was successful. We’ve wanted to be more involved with the actual implementation of the projects because then we may have given them a training, but it’s not enough. Some of the groups have to change their whole culture or may need a new structure to really implement what we’ve giving them, like how to effectively use culture in organizing…In terms of client work, we haven’t figured out what is the exact impact of what we did for them or worked with them on. We’ve been grappling with that.

We do a survey about the training afterwards with those types of questions, and then engage one-on-one with the participants.

Trainers raised a few additional points about the relationship of their training work to the impact of their trainees’ efforts:

We’ve done all these trainings. People have asked for them, they clearly need them and think they need them, but we don’t actually know if a particular training led to a campaign winning or X number of additional chapters being formed or whatever secondary metrics they were going after. I know I can’t back up our work as trainers quantitatively or with a perfectly great narrative or numbers, except say 12,000 copies of the book were sold to people who clearly thought it was worth spending money on, and it’s translated into seven languages.

One thing the trainees did that we thought was really impressive was they started doing test protests. They would do a protest but they didn’t call media, it was just like testing how far they could go with the target.

The more we can give our agents (trainees) the tools to create the intervention that is right for the culture of the debate that they’re in, the better. And so, yes, of course, they have to be effective, and they have to then be effective in terms of how it affects the culture shift.

  1. No consensus on who’s driving need for assessment

While most feel there is increased focus on evaluation and assessment in the field, there’s a variety of opinion on who is driving this thinking. Some see it as self-induced — organizations just wanting to do a better job of understanding the effect of their work. Others feel that the evaluation of programmatic work of NGOs has creeped into the world of advocacy where different rules and outcome apply. And more esoteric questions about who is trying to convince whom of what.

Our initiative is unusual enough that for one, it’s very hard to find funders, and two, the ones who we do find understand it at a more intuitive level of what we’re doing. And of course, there are metrics that we support, but it doesn’t feel like a heavy-handed mandate.

It’s hard to have traditional measuring tools. I think people have settled on the idea that there is no measurement, you can’t measure these things. There are foundations or other institutions demanding these tools that don’t work.

[On who’s driving need for assessment] I think it’s coming from our desire, but we’ve been pushed a little – (1) We recognize that we’ll be more effective fundraisers if we can build the case, and demonstrate results. So that’s why I make a concerted effort to raise money that’s sustainable. (2) It comes from our own desire to know more about how effective we’re being or whether we need to course correct. And (3), it’s also further propelled by the fact that we are one of four nonprofits that were selected for two years by a nonprofit incubator called Beespace, that has given us a bunch of seed money as well as a ton of in-kind support through hiring consultants and coaches.

There’s also a question of who are we trying to convince, and of what? Are we trying to convince funders? Are we trying to convince economists? Are we trying to convince advocacy organizations? And to do what? To spend more money on this stuff?   You know, to respect the role of art and culture? Those are my questions.

There’s some focus on impact but coming from just internally…We just self-reflected and made some adjustments or looked at the things that changed. We haven’t gone to a level of defining our measuring tools, but it’s been more like our self-evaluation.

I think it’s the whole NGO system, it’s not the funders. It’s more the NGOs who want funding saying,” we’ll guarantee your investment by measurement. We can measure our impact.” I think it’s as simple as that. Though I think it doesn’t do any good for activists…

  1. The role of process or interim metrics

Some participants raised the issue of the importance of process or interim metrics involved in the development of interventions and how these might be assessed. Because a lot of what is desired is in these interventions is affective, there is a need to look more closely at process than most traditional forms of evaluation.

The critical part at the end of the journey in understanding what we’ve learned, and how do we take this all-volunteer energy that is capitalized and turned into something more focused or impactful.

Did you actually have an artist sitting at your strategy table? Did you have a cultural worker there? Did you do an assessment of what kind of cultural pieces are within your community group to speak to the people that you’re trying to outreach to, or to involve them, or to build on your power internally? All that stuff can happen, but it’s not in any kind of organized fashion. And it’s very much part of the DNA of the movement, and that is the case.

I think one of the basic functions that cultural work serves is that it allows people to work together and figure out how to work together. They’ve got a basic function that we need to move towards, how do we work together better? How do we make decisions collectively better? And so that’s a function that arts and culture helped with. How do you measure that?

  1. Love the media metrics, hate the media metrics

There is a love/hate relationship with media metrics. Most interviewees recognize that media metrics are interim measures of their interventions’ impact that can provide good value and demonstrate visibility. And, as many artistic activism interventions rely on media pick-up to spread the word of the intervention, and because they can be relatively easily measured, they play an important part in many efforts. There is a critical recognition that media attention as a means can become an end in itself. Social media metrics also provide immediate response and great data on audiences, but practitioners often don’t have the time, resources or knowledge to fully measure, analyze and apply learnings.

On the flip side, because it is often hard to measure ultimate outcomes, in many cases media metrics have become a proxy for outcome metrics. Trainers/practitioners are recognizing that media metrics need to be assessed for the quality of engagement they provide. And many long for better ways to measure the social or political change they seek to effect. Media metrics also raise the question of whether a separate communications plan is needed in addition to the actual intervention.

I wouldn’t call it the metric (we’re looking for). Visibility is always a goal. Of course, we give all our agents press templates and everything like that, but you’re not always sure you get the three local media pieces.

It’s harder to get the primary metrics, like how has it (the intervention) affected the hearts and minds of America or the world. Then you fall back on the secondary metrics, but then you can franchise these metrics. These secondary metrics become a stand-in as you’re just wondering am I being effective, am I changing anything… so you fall back on friends on your Facebook page, likes for this thing, comments to this…YouTube clicks, et cetera. In some ways that is an indication of whether you’re striking a chord, whether you’re hitting your audience, but it’s not always a good indication. So much happens online. There are these strange ephemeral numbers that give you a little endorphin boost every time it clicks. Same thing goes for fundraising. Every time you set up a fundraising email and the dollars come back in you think that you’re being successful. The point is that it’s not how many people watch your thing but if you’re really clear on your audience…you could have a thousand influencers in this particular space, whether they’re state legislators or scientists in some kind of professional association and are moved and influenced…That’s better than a million hits on some kind of wacky viral video who are going to be amused by it and send it to friends but are not going to have any bearing on the issue. Sometimes a video with 500 views is better than one with two million views. It all depends on being precise and targeting and knowing how the outreach channels, which is more important than the hilarity of your content. We didn’t have the resources or the precision to be able to do that pre-poll, post-poll, targeted outreach thing to know if we were persuading any voters. We had to rely on column inches and number of chapters formed and all that kind of stuff.

With the Natural History Museum, and the letter that we’re doing right now around Standing Rock, we grew our email list to 100,000 in one year from scratch. We got 552,000 petition signatures to get David Koch off the board of the American Museum of Natural History. We built a network of 150 of the world’s top scientists, including several Nobel laureates. We now have about 800 museum professionals, directors, senior staff signed on to a political letter. That’s the “by-the-numbers” stuff, but then how do those numbers translate into impact? Well, we look at media hits and then assess them not just for reach and number of hits. Around the sciences letter we released, it was something like 150 news hits around the world in the biggest outlets, and covered by news, science, climate, higher education, philanthropy, and arts and culture reporters. That’s impact! But is just getting news coverage enough to change the game?… You can suggest that it’s changing the conversation, but then we look for some qualitative assessment of that news coverage. Is it good? Is it on message? Is it communicating something different? Then we dug deeper to see if that coverage and these petition signatures actually impacted the conversation in the sector we’re trying to transform. Now we’re in the middle of a several month-long curator stakeholder research phase, conducting a ton of interviews with museum professionals, scientists, and environmental justice groups. We want to get a sense of what’s changed over the last two years since we launched the projects, and to inform our strategies moving forward.

Those “by-the-numbers” metrics around this notion of are we building power, a counter-power, and are we changing and transforming understanding of the goals or institutions that we’re intervening upon? I think they can be distilled into measurable, quantifiable things. But that’s challenging, and I think it requires an investment in time and a particular expertise in measuring and in evaluation, that most artists and cultural producers engaged in activism either aren’t trained in or don’t fucking have time to do.

[re the NYC Climate March] You could see the proliferation of hashtags for more complex narratives around climate change. I would love to see people do studies around these new areas that were introduced during the Climate March that had previously not been talked about, stuff like the relation between climate change and immigration, for example.

Social media is not getting at the heart of why these issues are meaningful and powerful, and mobilize human labor on a massive scale towards a particular goal.

I think social media is actually a stepping stone metric. It’s the first time we’ve actually able to measure the way in which people are responding to something on a massive level. Some people are just saying, “well how can we get more hits, how can we get more views?” And then there are all kinds of artificial ways to create that. So, people are going after the metric rather than the thing that actually causes the metric. We’re tricking ourselves in the lab, so to speak. I don’t think we have yet found metrics that really show meaning, but I do think that when you see massive levels of people willing to undertake risk, willing to exert their energy, particularly when they’re not being compensated by anything else, that’s when you start to see human meaning being actualized in concrete form.

Social media pickup is a big one. Sometimes you’ll get how the story is reported, like what the messaging is and whether it stays on message or not. And then you have this other metric. It’s just basically like what other people are doing. Like if people are laughing a lot, that’s how we know it worked. Or, if they’re very moved somehow emotionally, that might show it also worked. Also email feedback is another one that we like. We might get an email that says, “Thank you! This is amazing.” We used to get a lot more of that than we do now.

There are a couple different measurements. One is simply number of articles or amount of media attention and the quality of media attention. For the BBC thing we did, there were 600 articles in the U.S. press that wouldn’t have been there otherwise.

The Chamber of Commerce thing that begins our third movie resulted in a huge amount of press, and two weeks later the Chamber of Commerce actually caved and changed positions. It wasn’t because of our action, but it didn’t hurt. It was a drop in the bucket, at least. We can’t judge and say that actually resulted in that change, but it did add a lot of embarrassment to the Chamber of Commerce and a lot of attention paid to the Chamber of Commerce, and they became more worried about pressure.

People forget media stories very, very quickly. We went around a year after our BBC announcement, which was by far our most successful action ever and still is. We asked people in London if they remembered it, and nobody did. I think a couple of people did have vague memories of it. But it really doesn’t stick around. Whereas with our movies, I think our actions do make a difference. I think people see them and go, “oh, I could do something, too” … You have time to build an argument and to really let it sink in, develop characters and the whole thing. People get involved in the story. With the media action, they don’t get involved in the story.

And so, then the evaluation becomes the media roundup. And if you have a big enough organization or you have enough time – i.e., persons who track media – that will make it easy enough.

  1. Other metrics can be more engaging

Participants noted a number of other ways their interventions and activities could be measured and evaluated aside from media metrics. Many talked about how the narrative of an issue had changed, or new narratives were started, how new players entered the conversation, how morale was raised among advocates, what relationships were formed, how quickly ideas spread, etc. They also talked about the numerous unexpected (positive) consequences that occurred as a result of interventions.

Most found these metrics as being much more difficult to measure over time. Some also raised the issue of culture shifting. Many felt the actual law, policy or activity that they were trying to change was the ultimate metric. There were also jabs taken at the “nonprofit industrial complex” for their embrace of a culture of metrics and assessment that some feel should not be applied to this kind of advocacy work.

Our campaign was really changing the environment in which the campaign was happening. We were reaching “persuadables” in the right districts and the right states. We were getting these memes circulating and making our side feel sexier, raising the morale, giving journalists some more useful ways to talk about the issues and bringing up issues that hadn’t been brought up before, even if we ended up losing the election. Sometimes these secondary metrics are kind of what a particular effort is about.

There are intangible best practices and some are more tangible, like how do you win, how do you force the target to cry uncle and do what you want, and also how do you stay healthy while doing this work. Everything along that spectrum…how do you build community, how do you give people a meaningful experience, how do you operate ethically? All of these things, as well as how do you come away with the victory, whether that’s passing a piece of legislation or forcing a company to stop a bad practice or whatever. I think one of our metrics is to turn young people on to activism broadly, but also to instigate or foster or contribute to a culture of analysis, even though our version of it is not particularly quantitative. It is very analytical in terms of tactics and practices and strategic principles and how to make the theory shit that we learn…how to bring it to bear and make it relevant, why does it matter? How do you quantify that shit? That’s hard.

What’s forefront are relationships, and from that, I think we can have very meaningful dialogue around impact

How you measure culture shift is really hard, but it has to do with how people are treating each other, how a community sees itself, how the story of the community is changing and scripted by a community…I feel we have great, great qualitative press, we do a lot of storytelling about our work.

If we want to see how a new narrative was injected into the popular discourse, that’s a really interesting question, and I think there are answers to some degree… The economic crisis started in 2008. And really, there wasn’t a whole lot of talk about it, but suddenly Occupy happened, and there’s massive proliferation of the term “income equality” through the media that dovetails perfectly to the day of the kind of public life of the Occupy movement.

I think a lot of the conversation on metrics has been damaging because the things that are the most measurable are sometimes the least important. And I think that the most important ones are often the least measurable. As a result, the metrics and the money and support and the institution building all go in the other direction… I actually think this explains a huge amount of the diversion of the left for the last 30 years into professional forms of organizing that have actually depleted the things that are effective and meaningful. And that’s why most of the collective organizing that I see, that is really shifting the discourse, is coming almost totally outside of the professional vendors. We built up a nonprofit industrial complex for 30 years, and it coincided with total increase in the power of the left. And then these breakthroughs are happening from almost totally outside the system that we created in order to address the problem.  

If we look at massive occupations, like Black Life Matters, that activists are doing, then we start to see a much more concrete manifestation of how meaning is motivating people to undertake these forms of action. And if there are ways to get at that, then I think we’re going to get a lot closer to finding things to help increase the accuracy and power of the kind of work that we’re all doing.

If we don’t get a lot of media attention for things, we don’t despair. We think of a secondary use for the material. Like this gun control thing we recently did, it got a certain amount of attention because the NRA reacted a certain way and took down thousands of websites, and it turned into a story. But what we’re really doing with that piece is turning it into a television pilot.

I think the most important thing is to build movements and bring new people into them, make people more activated. That can be done with or without media attention. It just happens to be what we’ve enjoyed doing and are good at and do. It’s not necessarily the best way to do it.

I really saw New York change, its people, after Occupy. They were different. They didn’t go after jobs as they did before. They started to think changing some things in their own lives because they didn’t work for them anymore.

So even with our Natural History Museum project where we have sort of traditional metrics for success, we’re still aiming for something beyond that. The world of metrics lives down here, but it’s like above this level of getting museums to do X, Y, Z, there’s this level. And above that there’s this level, and above that there’s universal egalitarian emancipation? I don’t know how you fucking measure that. How do you measure culture change? I think it is measurable. You can look at things like how much are people talking more about something, how much are things being initiated independent of you. Is it just this stuff that you’re doing as a heavy lift, or has it become contagious? Is it manifesting in ways that you hadn’t even imagined, like when the Black Congressional Caucus stages a Black Lives Matter and walks out themselves. Or the American Anthropological Association has a die-in with 1000 anthropologists in the middle of their convention. Wow. We didn’t plan on that, so really those are things to think about in tracking and communicating.

I think this is where the question of counter power and contagiousness come together, because if you’re producing things that are not associated with an individual, they can be contagious because they become signifiers of a collectivity. The measure of success is that they become something that other people pick up and use. So, for example, a hashtag is an example of that. For years, we were producing all these props. We would organize a demonstration and we would lay them out as people used them, then that was a measure of success. They started to be reproduced in other cities or around the world, then that was another measure of success.

  1. Limited use of other methodologies for measurement

Overall, there was little reported use of methodologies from other fields to help assess artistic activism interventions. Social marketing was mentioned by a few. The design field and PR were also cited. To put things in perspective, one practitioner suggested that all fields struggle with measuring impact.

Social marketing might be a tool that could be useful for us.

We look a lot at design but not exactly from a measurement point of view, but use design as a way to assess if the product or tool that we’re creating actually has an effect on someone, is it useful. That’s the only other field we’ve looked at.

(on PR) Corporations send out press releases all the time, news videos. They never reveal that they’re hoaxes. We do. But we use exactly the same kinds of techniques except that we reveal the hoax.

Measuring impact is not done well across pretty much every field.

  1. On language

Many pet peeves about the language used in artistic activism, and especially the language regarding measurement and assessment, surfaced during the interviews. Some feel that language issues often block great ideas from developing or being able to fully describe the impact practitioners are seeking. “Alienating” was a commonly repeated phrase for this language, and the need for different words or grammar of assessment was called for.

I guess” strategic” and “creative” are handmaidens to being more effective, possibly…though they may also be useful in their own way…I think “impact” is something that we know is important, and know that it matters to funders. We want it to matter to funders. We want the money to go where it could be most practical, but I would say we have a little bit of trepidation around that word.

I think that there is this NGO-ish strain in artistic activism that uses the word “culture” more than “art”. And “impact producers.” When you get into documentary film or media projects or video, there’s this whole ancillary industry of consultants or contractors that try to translate the arts or the media into “impact and upscale responsibility.” But in the world of art, which is where we’ve historically been a little more ensconced, people say “socially engaged art.” I think that these metrics for success, or ROI, or whatever you call them, is sort of alien and I completely understand why it annoys people.

I think we’ve internalized a lot of professional language. There are many historical reasons why we did that. I don’t think it’s helped us. These are all arbitrary languages. None of them have any inherently deeper grasp on the problems, and when we use the language of a particular community we’re communicating to people, “Yes, you are part of this, or no, you are not.” So, I think some of that language could be alienating.

If you use “measurement” and “evaluation” with my local activist group, they’re going to be like, yeah, whatever, and give you the glazed-over look.

Conflicts like climate change need something different in terms of language, something that we have to believe in. We don’t have the words, we don’t have the grammar we need. We can only create the right words if we really change ourselves. We need to break ourselves apart from our capitalistic selves to do this.

  1. What would be useful?

Participants cited a few areas where new tools and thinking would be helpful for them. Simple assessment tools that were not reliant on a lot of number crunching was one area suggested. A better understanding of how relationships form between people and groups in the organizing process was another area mentioned, as well as understanding how collective identities work and how they attract people to a movement or action. There was also interest in looking at how iconic movements or actions, like Rosa Parks sitting in the white section of the bus, actually inspired social change. Or knowing what the tools are to analyze such a change. One participant mentioned that having a better understanding of how artistic activism works could be useful in convincing large unions or other groups to utilize artistic activism more often. Easy to use assessment tools and tools that are human scale were called for.

If you can vet some easy to use assessment tools, but also roundup some of the best stuff out there, that would help. Assessment tools to understand your audience. There’s a lot of academic assessment tools, things that are going to matter for just multi-million dollar grants or obscure journals. They may be important but we’re not in a position to make use of that. I would imagine 99 percent of the work-a-day activists and artists aren’t either. Tools that are human scale that we can lay our hands on and actually use in the course of own practice, where people are really busy and have limited capacity, resources and training in this area. Something where there aren’t too many numbers…numbers that matter in terms of really being able to evaluate things…besides just list shit.

[re 2014 Climate March] What we were able to see was how this was operating collectively at a very large scale, and creating new webs of relationships that many of them are doing to this day – a number of organizations came out of that effort, as well as things like shifting the popular narrative around these issues. I guess the short answer is I think that we need more metrics around collaborative mobilization about relational density, looking at the densification of relationships within certain communities that are engaged in the creative practice, as well as a marriage just on a large scale.

It would be really interesting to see a focus on the way that new identities – collective identities, political identities – are created. I think a lot of that has to do with artistic practice… when you look at Occupy as an identity, Black Lives Matter as an identity, Creative Defenders as an identity, you see that people are highly motivated to act because they have internalized that identity. It has become meaningful to them. But it’s something that is shared with other people… if you look at the history of the labor movement, so much of the art and culture that accompanied it was about who we are as a labor movement and as a working-class people. There was a class identity. It was about union membership and it wasn’t just about contract fights and negotiations and policy, it was about redefining who is “we” and who is the “they,” and creating that narrative that people, that story that people were then living with the activism.

I was thinking of those historical examples that are really large in our imagination as having worked. Certain examples of some symbolic action that caused a social movement – I would be really curious to try to understand the relative success or value of those actions. I’m curious about it because I think a lot of times you think of creative actions as something that’s kind of new, even though it’s been going on forever… Was Rosa Park sitting on the bus effective? It was important in the civil rights movement. I think if you asked most people they would say yes, it was. But I don’t know how you would actually measure it. I’m sure there’s a way. These symbolic moments have played such a huge role in our understanding of these histories, we assume that they’re important.

Take the unions, for example. They do a lot of planning. They have the resources to do it. They have professional researchers on their staff, there is a lot of money on the line and there’s a lot of economic impact. They want to know how will this benefit my members; how will this impact the local economy if we’re able to unionize this plant. They are also sort of sketchy about the value of creativity and arts. If you could really develop a tool or tell some stories where you make the case that this is valuable and important and strategic, and you make the case with numbers or hard data of some kind in the kind of language that they respect…where artists were brought in on the ground floor and were able to help craft the messaging and designed a good website as opposed to a crappy union made website. That would be really powerful and that’s where someone who gets it, who has that instinct, can then use this truth, if you will, or data, to make the case up the chain. That’s where this could be really useful, and it’s not just in unions but could be in art NGOs and elsewhere.

  1. On why they’re not doing more evaluation

Time, money and lack of skills or knowledge are typical reasons why activist/practitioners haven’t done more evaluation of their work, as well as more of a focus on strategy rather than a comprehensive program that includes evaluation.

It’s something that requires different skill sets than what we have. Things like polling, focus groups, etc. We were looking into prices of doing research through a focus group company, and the prices were so exorbitant that there was no way we could afford to do it anyway… A lot of groups test their emails to see how people respond and pick up and stuff like that. We’ve never done that. There are only a couple of us and we’re all part-time. (laughs) We try to write a good email and sometimes it doesn’t really work the way it’s supposed to. But it’s probably our fault for not actually testing it with a small sample…If we had to hire somebody to do it, we probably wouldn’t because we’re pretty strapped for cash and time.

Measuring impact is not only having things in place to measure –we very rarely have any money to do it… the whole field is dominated by strategic methodology pieces, and so funders and organizations and people sitting down to do strategy don’t pay enough attention to evaluation.

  1. Thoughts on a standard framework

Participants were intrigued by the idea of a standard framework for evaluating artistic activism interventions. They would be willing to give it a try if they felt it could offer value for understanding how the intervention works. A methodology that included both objective (numbers and metrics) and subjective (story) elements would be of most interest.

I have a feeling it would be hard to come up with something that would be one-size fits all, but it would still be very useful…there’s no standard for reporting in the media, but you can choose one side or another side, and I think metrics, how you read metrics, are the same thing. So basically, there’s a radical way of reading metrics and then there’s a conservative way of reading metrics. And I think that basically this is like the argument for the story that the metrics tell, so I’d be more concerned about the story that people tell about the metrics than the metrics themselves.

Yes, if it can help us see into some of those black boxes, some of the dark areas. We’re trying to see the dark matter that’s out there and detect it and really understand it. If we can somehow observe the process that happens between a work of art and an idea reaching a community, and then that community taking a defiant form of action, that’s the black box.

Implications/Recommendations

Implications

These interviews suggest that there is no standard thinking about the topic of aefficacy in artistic activism projects. While there are some individuals and groups that follow very focused and regimented methods for planning their interventions, there appears to be a looser need for formalization. That said, much more energy is put into the planning phases of interventions than to the assessment/evaluation phase. As some trainers only work with groups through implementation, the assessment/evaluation piece is sometimes an afterthought to them and/or their trainees. Pressure from funders often instigates formal assessment reporting.

Despite some resistance to or resentment of this pressure from funders, most interviewees would like to have better assessment tools. For many, press coverage/media metrics become their de-facto evaluation method. While these metrics may provide a lot of information and data, most feel that they are intermediary to the larger social change or advocacy goals they have set for their interventions. Participants feel they often don’t know enough about media metrics and don’t have the time or resources to bring other measures or resources into their processes. Interestingly, many of the measures they mentioned they would like to bring into their processes are not that difficult to assess. They do require more thought during the up-front planning phase of interventions.

The majority of those interviewed would be interested in tools that could help them better assess their work. The tools need to be easy to follow, and need to have the right balance of hard data (metrics) and soft information (storytelling). Some feedback loops with these practitioners would be helpful as these tools are developed to ensure they are on track in terms of content, and that they would actually be utilized.

Recommendations

Based on these findings and implications, it is suggested that C4AA take the following steps as we proceed with this project:

  • Investigate the organizations/individuals whom interviewees think are doing good work to add to the learning.
  • Ensure that toolkits for both practitioners and funders are easy-to-follow and implement, and make evaluation/assessment part of the planning process.
  • As part of the toolkit, draft a theory-of-change model that could be used on a turnkey basis by groups and organizations.
  • Investigate ideas for including easy-to-plan outcome metrics and data collection methods in the toolkit.

 


Discussion Guide for Trainers/Field Defining Organizations

Revised Draft May 23, 2016

 

Background

Following the recently conducted literature review, C4AA is interested in conducting interviews with artistic activism trainers and other “field-defining” organizations to expand the learning for this part of the AEfficacy project.

 

Objectives

The objectives for this research are to:

  • Build on the learning from the lit review
  • Understand the challenges and opportunities to developing a culture of measuring impact in the field
  • Learn what tools and techniques for assessment are currently being used in the field (or not) and how effective they are
  • Identify potential tools that would be helpful to the field and what needs to be done to develop them

 

Methodology

Participants were sent a copy of the lit review report and asked to read it before the interview to provide them with some context. Where possible, multiple members of an organization will be interviewed together. Interviewees will be told up front that they will be audiotaped and that their comments (with attribution) may be used in a report that will be developed as a final stage of the project. The interviewer will also provide a brief summary of the project and its work to date at the beginning of the conversation.

 

Key Questions

 

Background

  • What is the service your organization provides and with what audiences do you work?
  • What is the basic process you use for your training or project development?
  • What theories of change or frameworks underlie the work you do?

 

Issues around measuring impact

  • Overall thoughts about measuring impact of artistic activism
    • How do you define impact?
    • How well does the field do this?
    • How well do you do this?
    • Is there a focus on measuring impact in the field now? If not, how can it be developed – or is it needed at all?
    • Anyone in the field doing a good job?
    • Who’s driving the process? Funders? Academics? Others?
    • Were any of the tools or ideas mentioned in the lit review relevant to your work?
  • Challenges in regard to assessment and evaluation
    • Is it part of your planning/training process?
    • Do you set goals/objectives? Is there a specific behavior, law or practice you are looking to change?
    • Are there models or frameworks you utilize? Are they useful? What’s missing?
    • Are there specific metrics you use?
      • Outreach, new audiences, media pick up, social media buzz, attitude, behavior or policy change, etc.
    • Do you utilize models from other fields (which) and if so, what works best?
    • What are the specific issues you have regarding measurement and assessment?
    • And what do you think of the language used? Measurement, Impact, Evaluation, Assessment, Effect?
    • Does it matter if artistic activism projects are effective?
    • Who measures such work currently for you or other organizations?

 

What’s needed?

  • Would a standard framework, model, or theory of change for impact measurement in the field be helpful to you? How might you use it?
  • What would need to be part of it?
  • How should it be developed?

 

Anything else you would like to share about the topic?


ÆFFICACY Project

Created: 28 Apr 2017

Measuring the Impact of Artistic Activism

AKA “The Æffect Project”

In 2015 the C4AA teamed up with George Perlov, former VP of Research at the Ad Council, and currently with George Perlov Consulting,  to study the æffect of artistic activism. What we’re looking for are answers to the question “Does Artistic Activism Work?” and what are the metrics we should use for measuring the practice?

To answer these questions we’ve designed a research project that will start from the bottom up: working with practicing artistic activists to develop appropriate measures of success. 

Measuring the Impact of Artistic Activism

Background
Social change is hard. Over the years social issue campaigners and activists have employed a variety of marketing and communications efforts to attract public interest to their issues and causes to varying degrees of success. More recently, activists have turned to the arts for inspiration and as a way to engage audiences through deep and emotional connections to create more powerful and meaningful interactions. At the same time, more artists are imbuing their work with social and political messaging to advance the issues they feel most passionate about.

Now that there is a growing body of work in the field, as well as a host of different training programs available to artists and activists, there is an opportunity to develop common definitions, best practices and a generic working theory-of-change model for artistic activism programs. What we’re looking for are answers to the question “Do these practices work?” and what are the metrics we should use for measuring them?

Why study this?

Like any burgeoning field of social intervention practice, we need a common vocabulary, established practices, a shared understanding of how these efforts actually work (or don’t) and an appropriate metrics with which to evaluate success. We need the collective knowledge of leaders in the field to help codify what we believe to be true anecdotally. This knowledge will help not only help trainers and academics work more efficiently and collaboratively, but also provide a basic knowledge base to novice and experienced practitioners. It will also help to demonstrate the impact of this kind of work to a larger and more diverse group of funders to help them recognize these interventions as effective practices worthy of their investments.

Key Questions

Some of the key questions we expect that this initiative will address include:

  • How have artistic activism projects changed attitudes, beliefs and behaviors of target audiences?
  • What kind of practices have been most successful and why? What best practices can be documented?
  • What sort of evaluative strategies do trainers and practitioners employ?
  • What opportunities exist to expand, continue or sustain time and/or place-based interventions?
  • What language do practitioners, trainers, academics and other use to describe interventions?
  • Is there consensus on a generic Theory-Of-Change model for artistic activism?
  • What metrics should be used for evaluating impact of these practices?
  • What other needs exist currently in the field?

 

Proposed Methodology/Work Plan

We propose a multi-phase work plan that will help to answer these questions:

  • Formation of an Advisory Committee – An advisory committee comprised of academics, practitioners, trainers and funders of artistic activism projects will be formed and convened over the project period to provide overall guidance, counsel and direction for the project.
  • Literature Review – A literature review of any existing articles, reports, case studies and other documentation of artistic activism will be undertaken and findings summarized.
  • TheoryOf-Change Model – Based on existing information and data, a generic Theory-Of-Change model for the field of artistic activism will be developed for Advisory Committee input and consensus building. We will also highlight potential metrics that could be used to measure impact for discussion.
  • Stakeholder interviews – To complement the feedback received from the Advisory Committee, additional interviews on the state of the field will be conducted among additional stakeholders and experts to provide an expanded viewpoint on the field.
  • Observation of training programs – The principal researcher will observe a few different training programs provided by different organizations to understand the various approaches, taxonomies and systems used to train newcomers to field.
  • Analysis and recommendations – A digital report will be developed that synthesizes all of the learnings, discussions, the final Theory-Of-Change model developed, and other best practices from the field.
  • Toolkits – Toolkits for both artists and activists will be developed so that they can incorporate the learning from this work into the art they create/programs they develop.
  • Dissemination — The digital report and toolkits will be disseminated widely among the foundation, social marketing and artistic activism communities as well as among key bloggers in the field, and a plan will be developed for opportunities to present the findings and opportunities at conferences and meetings.

ÆFFECT ADVISORY BOARD

Created: 28 Apr 2017

Artistic Activism Efficacy Advisory Board

 

Kenneth Bailey — Founder, Design Studio for Social Intervention

Luis Camnitzer — Independent artist

James Chung — Founder, Reach Advisers

Brett Davidson — Program Director, Open Society Foundations

Kathy Eldon — Founder, Creative Visions      

Deborah Fisher — Executive Director, A Blade of Grass

Jessica George — Executive Director, Revolutions Per Minute

Silas Harrebye — Professor, Roskilde University, Denmark  

Rob Horowitz — Founder, ArtsResearch  

John Johnson — Founder, Harmony Institute

Antanas Mockus, Corpovisionarios

Doris Sommer — Professor, Harvard University, and founder, Cultural Agents

Diana Taylor — Professor, NYU, and Director, Hemispheric Institute of Performance and Politics      

Nato Thompson — Curator, Creative Time

Rise Wilson – Director of Philanthropy, Rauschenberg Foundation


LITERATURE REVIEW

Created: 28 Apr 2017

Center for Artistic Activism

Measuring the Impact of Artistic Activism

Literature Review Report

DRAFT March 25, 2016

 

Background

Social change is hard. Over the years, social issue campaigners and activists have employed a variety of marketing and communications efforts to attract public interest to their issues and causes to varying degrees of success. More recently, activists have turned to the arts for inspiration and as a way to engage audiences through deep and emotional connections to create more powerful and meaningful interactions. At the same time, more artists are imbuing their work with social and political messaging to advance the issues they feel most passionate about.

 

Now that there is a growing body of work in the field, as well as a host of different training programs available to artists and activists, there is an opportunity to develop common definitions, best practices and a generic working theory-of-change model for artistic activism programs. What we’re looking for are answers to the question “Do these practices work?” and what are the metrics we should use for measuring them?

 

The project is being managed by a team from The Center for Artistic Activism and George Perlov Consulting, with support from an Advisory Committee of academics, practitioners and others with extensive experience in the field. (see Appendix for member list). As a first step in this process, George Perlov Consulting and the Center for Artistic Activism (the project team) conducted a literature review of the field to see what information, reports and research exist on the topic of measuring the impact of artistic activism.

 

The supporting Excel spreadsheet contains links to the documents we feel are important for this analysis with additional background and commentary on them (Some documents are available via a Dropbox that can be shared if interested, and some are library books that have been reviewed for inclusion). We envision the literature review as the first step of an extensive investigation and planning process to better understand the issues, challenges and opportunities to better evaluate this kind of work and to provide tools to practitioners to support them in their future efforts.

 

Methodology

In order to delimit the process, the project team developed the following parameters for the literature review:

  • References should be international
  • Could be present or historical
  • The kinds of art should be visual, performative, conceptual, sound (but not music)
  • Our working definition of activism was intentional action to bring about political, economic, social change

 

The project team also divided the review into different tiers, with the decision to put the most focus on the first tier:

  1. Studies on the effect/affect of artistic activism
  2. Studies on the affect/affect of kindred fields like documentary films and photography educational/community/socially engaged theatre or music
  3. Studies on the effect/affect of tangential fields like “artful” social marketing or propaganda
  4. Contextual theory: cognition, aesthetics/art, philosophy

 

A call for submissions was sent to a broad group of stakeholders in the fall of 2015 (see email draft in appendix) which was supplemented by a web and database search, as well as recommendations from the project team. In total about 80 references were assembled. The project team then edited the list to conform to the abovementioned parameters/tiers and ended up reviewing and analyzing about 50 references. The literature review is considered a working document to be updated over time.

 

A note on language used in the search

There is a wide variety of language used to describe the field of artistic activism, much of it depending on the author. For artists or artist-led initiatives, terms like “socially engaged art” or “social practice” are commonly used, while activist-led efforts tend to use “artistic activism” or “creative activism” more commonly. For the purpose of the web and online search, we used these terms, as well “political art” and “cultural activism” along with definers such as “Impact of…,” “effect of,” “evaluation of…” or best practices in…” to conduct our online and database search.

 

Defining Artistic Activism

For this report, we are using a working definition of artistic activism developed by the Center for Artistic Activism as paraphrased below:

 

Activism, as the name implies, is the activity of challenging and changing power relations, what the political scientist Harold Lasswell once defined as “who gets what, when and how.” The goal of activism is Action to generate an Effect. Art, on the other hand, doesn’t have such a clear target. It’s hard to say what art is for or against; its value often lays in showing us new perspectives and ways to bring meaning to our lives. In short, art is an Expression that generates Affect.

 

At first glance the outcomes of Affect or Effect seem at odds with one another – they point in different directions.  Affect is personal, something one senses, manifesting itself in an individual, emotional response. Effect is more social, displaying universal, observable, and measurable results. We’re moved by affective experiences to do physical actions that result in concrete effects: Affect leads to Effect.  And concrete effects have affective impact, generating personal emotion: Effect leads to Affect.

 

The Center used to call this complimentary combination Affective Effect, or sometimes: Effective Affect. But it was too clumsy so they came up with a new word. Using the grapheme aesc, or Æ, they invented the term:

 

Æffect


Their belief is that Artistic Activists are always trying to have an æffect, creating an experience that generates a feeling that has demonstrable impact in the world.

 

This definition contrasts deeply with projects and activities that are seen in the field more commonly: social practice or socially engaged art, which typically are more focused on affect rather than effect, where effect might be unplanned or accidental. Artistic activism, by contrast, is rooted in creating measurable outcomes and impact that lead to concrete social or behavioral change.

Key Findings

Based on this definition, we found almost no literature (the exception being some essays from the Center for Artistic Activism and a few other sources – see below) on the topic of measuring the impact of artistic activism. What we did find was a fair amount written on the kindred fields of socially engaged art, public art, edutainment, political art, and fields like social marketing and other behavior change-related sectors.

 

We start our analysis by looking at some of the theoretical underpinnings of artistic activism that relate to the study of its impact and effectiveness, then move on to the few writings on the topic itself, and then look at the kindred fields from which we may deduce some thoughts and ideas that will be relevant to developing better tools and structures to assess the field more broadly. More information about the literature mentioned in this report can be found on the accompanying summary section of the spreadsheet and/or the source itself.

 

Theories behind artistic activism demonstrate challenges inherent in measuring/evaluating this discipline

A recent ArtNews article about social practice raises what might be the most basic questions and challenges of measuring the impact of artistic activism projects: “Should (these projects) be evaluated for the social changes they produce, for the elements of performance they incorporate, or for the esthetic qualities of the environments in which they take place?”

 

The Spectres of Evaluation report from the University of Melbourne also highlights some of the challenges of identifying what evaluation actually is, “Evaluation can include measures of efficacy, impact, value, best practice, advocacy, an independent audit, an opportunity for critical feedback from participants or descriptions of critical learnings, such as ‘what would we do differently next time?’ Evaluation can also range from systematic bureaucratic procedures delivered by external consultants and researchers to improvised group activities.”

 

TV Reed, in his essay, points out how the political and aesthetic movements have come together over the years. Some of the metrics he describes for measuring the intensity of cultural movements may also be applied to the evaluation of artistic activism projects. And Deborah Fisher, in her essay about how A Blade of Grass works, raises questions about the concept of power within the art and social justice movements, as many of these efforts rely on external funding sources.

 

All of these forces combine to make the process of assessing impact and even describing impact a challenge in the field. Questions also arise regarding what impact measures to utilize – should they be related to specific advocacy outcomes, mobilizing engaged audiences or reaching new audiences, for example.

 

Only a small number of reports and papers focus on artistic-activist programs (vs. artist –led) as well as the measuring/evaluation of them

Some highlights include:

  • The Michael Shank article, Redefining the Movement: Art Activism, which offers a strong theoretical approach to how artistic activism works, based on childhood learning patterns and the power of nonverbal communication, but without any focus on impact or assessment.
  • The ArtCorps paper on the theoretical underpinnings of their Central American training programs for activists. These include Integral Theory, Creative Learning, Multiple Intelligences and the Power of Art, Popular Education, Conflict Transformation Theory and Theory of Structural Violence.
  • The Astrea Lesbian Foundation’s report on the advocacy gains made by artistic interventions in social justice programs on transgender rights. Using a framework to identify public policy strategy, the author makes the case that the artistic interventions provided more upstream outcomes with a higher level of decision maker than typical awareness and education campaigns.

 

Measurement, evaluation and how “it” works is fairly developed in kindred fields

As we expected, there is a fairly developed literature on measurement and impact in a number of kindred fields – such as social marketing or “behavior change” marketing, and in more arts-oriented fields like public art, art education, edutainment, political art and socially engaged art or social practice as it is more commonly known. The latter topic is addressed in its own section below.

 

Social marketing

The McKenzie-Mohr text is one of many guides on the topic of social marketing available that lays out a theory of change and leads novices and more experienced practitioners on the steps necessary to develop and implement an effective behavior change campaign. In many ways, it is the processes described by McKenzie-Mohr and others in the field that provide the structural backbone of artistic activism, the effect part of the equation.

 

Edutainment

In the field of edutainment, the Lacayo and Singhal guide is comprehensive and identifies specific issues and concerns in evaluating edutainment programs and projects. It also includes thoughtful sections on evaluation.

 

 

Public Art and Civic Engagement

The report, Building Cultures – Art and Our City, takes the perspective of architects and city planners on what arts activism can add to the city planning process. And in the public art front, Research on Public Art: Assessing Impact and Quality, is a comprehensive report on theory, practice and evaluation in that discipline. Lastly, in terms of arts and civic engagement, the Animating Democracy report, Civic Engagement and the Arts: Issues of Conceptualization and Measurement, provides detailed theories of change, evaluations, and other information germane to that field.

 

Social Practice and Socially Engaged Art

The field of social practice and socially engaged art has been growing steadily over the years and new thinking about measuring its impact has been coming from various fronts:

 

A Blade of Grass’ (ABOG) exploration of the practicalities of measurement and evaluation is strong and raises important questions

As a producer/funder of a growing body of socially engaged art programs, some of which have been transformed into sustainable programs supported by public and private endeavors, ABOG’s ethnographic, multi-stakeholder approach to evaluation is providing good learning and beginning to identify standards of best practice in the field. And their work in documenting the programs is starting to create more of a voice for the importance of socially engaged art in the art world and beyond. They are also questioning issues like power and funder influence, as well as the slow pace of social change, how well versed in the social issue at hand does the artist have to be, and the “spectator” experience of projects that wouldn’t be considered art by traditional standards, like a pop-up library of Spanish literature.

 

New work from Animating Democracy is exploring some of the deeper nuances of evaluating socially engaged art and providing new frameworks

Animating Democracy’s new reports on aesthetic and values considerations of socially engaged art are building blocks for developing more sophisticated underlying theories and theories of change about this work; they are a testing ground for metrics and measures that can be utilized. For example, the values proposed in that paper,

  • Shared learning and understanding
  • Reciprocity
  • Collaboration
  • Context
  • Equity
  • Right-sized expectations
  • Appropriate metrics
  • Ethics
  • Adequately resourced

are fleshed out as potential evaluative indicators.

 

Similarly, their proposed aesthetic qualities,

  • Disruption
  • Authenticity
  • Communal meaning
  • Porosity
  • Risk taking
  • Stickiness
  • Commitment

include a series of questions that might be asked to also guide the evaluation process.

 

There are a few very good, comprehensive guides for socially engaged art that do include sections on planning, measurement and evaluation

Novices looking for support in the field have a lot of consolidated wisdom to support them. More notable guides are those listed below:

  • Created for the website Impact Arts, Callahan Consulting’s Evaluation Guides for Arts and Social Impact are intended for artists and “administrators” as well.
  • The very straightforward Creative Activist Toolkit by Creative Visions includes a step-by step guide for artists engaging in social practice and explanation of metrics for measurement. Similarly, the Revolutions-Per-Minute guide is tailored for its musician audience.
  • Making Waves: A Guide to Cultural Strategy, from the Culture Group provides artists and activists with historic examples and planning tools, however without any focus on evaluation.

 

A meta-analysis of these guides will be helpful as we begin to develop recommendations for the field.

 

Implications

We see the following as the two key implications from the initial review of this literature:

 

A small body of literature on the “bullseye” of measuring/evaluating impact of activist art

The majority of the literature identified so far is focused on what artists are doing to engage in their own social practice. Some literature exists on the theories of how it works, but there is no real theory of change established for the field nor specific evaluative tools or techniques germane to activists using artistic methods to achieve their goals.

 

Guides and frameworks from kindred fields are helpful for planning, but need for specialized tools in this field

While guides highlighted in this report from fields like public art, social practice and edutainment serve artists and practitioners in those fields, there is an absence of specialized tools for activists using art to further their causes. Activist-led projects and programs need more best practices, theories of change and tools for assessing impact.
                                 

More dialogue and discussion are planned to help shape this diagram as we begin to create better tools, tactics and language for measuring the impact of artistic activism.

 

Next Steps

Moving forward, we plan to share this document and the spreadsheet with members of the Advisory Committee for their input and additional suggestions. We will also continue to update the review with new documents and information so that it is a resource for others working in the field.

 

Appendix

 

 

Measuring the Impact of Artistic Activism

Lit Review Call for Submissions

 

Subject: Open call for Reports, Evaluations, Articles and other Documents that Measure the Impact of Artistic Activism

 

Dear XXXX,

 

As you may have heard, the Center for Artistic Activism is working on a study of the impact of artistic activism programs. As a first step, and with seed funding from the Open Society Foundations, our colleague George Perlov, former head of research and evaluation at the Ad Council and expert on measuring such things, is conducting a literature review on the topic.

 

We are reaching out today to see if you have any case studies, evaluations, reports, articles or other relevant documents from artistic activism programs you or colleagues have developed over the years to share with George. We are also interested in any theoretical frameworks developed for measuring such programs that might help us put some context around the issue.

 

Some additional details:

  • We are looking for evaluation of programs or initiatives conducted anywhere in the world.
  • New and historical efforts are welcome.
  • The “art” involved in the project should be visual, performative, sound-focused and/or conceptual.
    • Note: we are also interested in evaluations of documentary films, photography, music and educational, community or socially engaged theater, but as these fields are typically more established our focus is on the other types mentioned above.
  • Our working definition of activism is “action to bring about political, economic and/or social change.”

 

Should you have any questions, please feel free to reach out to George directly, copied above. And please forward any materials to him no later than September 21st. Thanks for your help and we look forward to sharing our learning with you.

 

Best regards,

 

Steve and Steve


Join Actipedia

Created: 28 Apr 2017

Actipedia is an open-access, user-generated database of creative activism. It’s a place to read about, comment upon, and ...

Press: We Make Money Not Art on C4AA and Artistic Activism

Created: 19 Apr 2017

Yesterday, We Make Money Not Art featured our webinars and one of our favorite examples of truly artistic

What Would Jesus Do? (as a Creative Activist)

Created: 14 Apr 2017

By C4AA Co-Founder Stephen Duncombe My proselytizing here is of a political rather than religious nature. It isn’t

Artistic Action: Sex Worker Rights in Dublin

Created: 22 Mar 2017

As part of our Arts Action Academy in December 2016 in Dublin, sex workers, artists and activists created and

5 Ways to Up Your Artistic Action Game

Created: 27 Feb 2017

Here are 5 things you can do if you want to make change in the world: 1. Steal ...

Beatrice Glow

Created: 15 Feb 2017

It’s a long wave. I think of everything as being interdependent or part of an ecosystem, philosophically and ...

Apply for the Johannesburg Art Action Academy

Created: 14 Feb 2017

Are you an artist or creative practitioner interested in challenging public perceptions about sex work in South Africa?

Imagine You Are A Superhero

Created: 27 Jan 2017

This is one of the favorite exercises in our trainings. It’s a good place to start if you’re ...

Artistic Activism at the UN

Created: 26 Jan 2017

Steve and Steve were at the United Nations this week, where they gave a presentation to the Arts ...

Elliot Crown

Created: 23 Jan 2017

Images operate the same way that memories do; images have this deep-seated attachment to your mind and I ...

Do petitions do anything?

Created: 28 Dec 2016

An article on the New York Times today looks at Change.org and whether online petition campaigns are truly ...

The Creators Project Recommends C4AA to Artists

Created: 20 Dec 2016

The fantastic Creators Project just posted a new story on us: “Need More Activism in Your Art? Look

Give the Gift of Artistic Activism

Created: 13 Dec 2016

Give your friends or family a can of Whoop Ass or Canned Do Spirit! Your gift will support ...

Federico Hewson

Created: 05 Dec 2016

[T]here’s socially engaged art, there’s socially engaged business, and there can also be socially engaged horticulture; flowers working

C4AA’s Steve Lambert talks Artistic Activism on Al Jazeera

Created: 04 Dec 2016

Steve Lambert was a panelist in-studio on Al Jazeera’s The Stream on Monday and Tuesday’s show. It aired

What we’ve been reading this week

Created: 14 Nov 2016

Donald Trump Will be President: This is What we do Next “…let’s exhale and let go of our ...

How to intervene if you witness Islamophobic harassment

Created: 12 Nov 2016

Artist Maeril made this illustrated guide a few months ago, but it’s now more relevant than ever. You

Most creative election ad of 2016?

Created: 26 Oct 2016

We don’t agree with his policies, but this ad is funny and very effective: Gerald Daugherty, a Republican ...

Felicia Young

Created: 29 Sep 2016

  My theory is one of creative collaboration and joyous affirmation — activating change through the inspirational power of

Diana Arce

Created: 01 Sep 2016

[T]he change has to come from socialization. It’s the way that people are being taught to interact with ...

André Leipold

Created: 11 Aug 2016

It’s not that we have a vision necessarily, but we try to poke holes in the scenery – ...

Amin Husain

Created: 29 Jul 2016

“Art actions relevant for today come from a place of vulnerability and radical love, from fighting back. They ...

Joey Juschka

Created: 25 Jul 2016

“[My] intention is to raise the topic, and on one side, be funny, and on the other side ...

Familiar vs. Novel – Everything is a Remix

Created: 19 May 2016

First, if you’ve never seen Everything is a Remix, go watch it now. It’s a great primer on ...

Ron Goldberg

Created: 24 Apr 2016

Going back to the early days at the March on Washington…to watch people respond to us as we ...

Andrew Boyd

Created: 15 Mar 2016

“I think there is something affirming of our humanity in culture – in the community building side of ...

How do you measure the impact of socially engaged art? 

Created: 25 Feb 2016

In our new Æfficacy project we’ve been working with our colleague George Perlov, thanks to funding from The Open

The Axes of Art and Activism

Created: 19 Feb 2016

What happens when 4 of the greatest minds in Æfficacy get together and brainstorm around creative activism? The Axes ...

And what do I do now? Using Data Visualization for Social Change

Created: 23 Jan 2016

Last week, the C4AA’s Steve Lambert attended the Responsible Data Forum on Data Visualization. In this article, Lambert

Koch Quits!

Created: 22 Jan 2016

Two days ago, in a big win for cultural institutions everywhere, it was announced that David H. Koch ...

Guerilla Girls on Colbert!

Created: 20 Jan 2016

The anonymous feminist art collective Guerrilla Girls appeared on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert Wednesday night and ...

P.T.S.D. ACTION MAN! PARALYZED ACTION MAN! DEAD ACTION MAN!

Created: 13 Aug 2015

http://battlefieldcasualties.co.uk/ Great use of comedy as an entry point for veterans issues. A Veterans for Peace UK film,

Awareness | 99% Invisible

Created: 13 Aug 2015

99% Invisible did a 20m piece on the AIDS Awareness ribbon last month. The ribbon was a project ...

Reclaim the suits!

Created: 10 Aug 2015

Back in 2002, Center Co-Director Stephen Duncombe took part in a “Rant-a-Thon” held as a fund raiser for ...

The Donald gets duped: Harvard Lampoon tricks Trump with phony endorsement — and he’s not happy about it | Salon

Created: 05 Aug 2015

The Donald’s been duped. In what’s been called a “a prank of presidential proportions,” the staff at Harvard

Edward Snowden monument placed (and removed) in New York City

Created: 07 Apr 2015

There’s a Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Monument in Brooklyn While most people

What are your Super Powers?

Created: 10 Mar 2015

It can sometimes be easier to focus on our weaknesses than our strengths – but like every Superhero, ...

Steve’s Super Hero Exercise

Created: 10 Mar 2015

Here’s a great exercise to help realize your inner superhero! Super Hero Exercise Curriculum by Steve Lambert Introduction

ACTIPEDIA REVISITED: THE PINK CHADDI CAMPAIGN

Created: 08 Mar 2015

It’s International Women’s Day! So this week, we’re taking a look at a really powerful piece of collective

ACTIPEDIA REVISITED: WOMEN ON WAVES

Created: 28 Feb 2015

So this week we’re doffing our caps to the work of Women on Waves, who worked with our ...

Formula for Success

Created: 23 Feb 2015

The formula is quite simple: if attained aeffect matches desired aeffect, then we’ve succeeded. If it doesn’t we’ve ...

ACTIPEDIA REVISITED: McDONALD’s VIDEOGAME

Created: 19 Feb 2015

This week we’re taking a look at the McDonald’s Videogame, where you own and operate a McDonald’s restaurant. In

Actipedia: Pigasus for President

Created: 17 Feb 2015

CHICAGO At the Democratic National Convention in Chicago in 1968, the Yippies (Youth International Party) nominated a pig ...

ACTIPEDIA REVISITED: PRINCESS HIJAB

Created: 12 Feb 2015

‘My art has nothing to do with religion.’ This week we’re throwing the spotlight on the guerilla street art

Actipedia revisited: Public Movement – ‘Re-Branding European Muslims’ (2012)

Created: 15 Jan 2015

Each week we’ll be calling back to an example of creative activism from our website Actipedia – an open-access, user-generated

An African’s Message for America

Created: 13 Jan 2015

A volunteer trip abroad has become almost a rite of passage for a certain set of Americans, particularly ...

Hell No, We Won’t Go: Outstanding Radical Art And Global Movements in 2014 | KQED Arts

Created: 01 Jan 2015

Great summary of “Outstanding Radical Art And Global Movements in 2014” from Christian L. Frock.

Sister Corita Kent says get out there and make it happen! (paraphrasing)

Created: 21 Dec 2014

A reminder from Sister Corita Kent & Emerson. Ideas must work through the brains and the arms of

A message from EverdayRebellion.net….

Created: 11 Dec 2014

A message from EverdayRebellion.net…. Help us change the world through spreading creative non-violent protest methods on our cross-media

New York Times Off Color: Kristina Wong uses humor to talk about race

Created: 04 Dec 2014

Off Color, a video series, highlights artists of color who use humor to make smart social statements about

Questions for Planning a Campaign – a worksheet courtesy of the CDC

Created: 01 Dec 2014

Doing some research for our book and I came across this worksheet from the Centers for Disease Control.

Restaurant Calorie Labeling and Obesity: Does it Work?

Created: 29 Nov 2014

A 620 calorie Starbucks Venti White Hot Chocolate is over 1/4 your recommended calories for the day1. But

How do people get new ideas?

Created: 02 Nov 2014

On Creativity by Isaac Asimov A recently discovered essay by the great SF writer written back in 1959, giving ...

When NOT to march (or rally)

Created: 03 Oct 2014

When NOT to march (or rally) by Andrew Willis Garces On an ordinary Tuesday evening in April 2007, ...

The Ark: Faith Leaders at Climate Change

Created: 02 Oct 2014

CAA had the privilege of working with faith leaders, activists, and community organizers last spring for a collaboration

NYPD ♥s CLIMATE JUSTICE

Created: 22 Sep 2014

Steve Lambert and Victoria Estok approached NYPD officers along the People’s Climate March, showed them their sign, and

The future and why we are terrible at predicting it « You Are Not So Smart

Created: 18 Apr 2014

I am listening to the You Are Not So Smart Podcast and reminded of how often Stephen Duncombe

#ThinkBikes campaign

Created: 20 Mar 2014

The AA Charitable Trust, part of the U.K.’s Automobile Association made this video as part of their #ThinkBikes ...

Raise the River Campaign

Created: 20 Mar 2014

A PSA that uses culture and humor: Raise the River vs. Move the Ocean …    

Follow the Frog by Rainforest Action Network

Created: 13 Mar 2014

A great example of using humor and social marketing techniques to make a very effective piece.

SARAH SILVERMAN IS VISITED BY JESUS CHRIST

Created: 27 Jan 2014

Great example of using humor to talk about difficult topics. Bravo.

REFLECTO-CUBE!

Created: 11 Jan 2014

The ukranians are using mirrors and in Europe, they have the Reflecto-Cube! It’s mentioned in an article “12 ...

Ukranian protesters use mirrors

Created: 03 Jan 2014

EcoLocalizer | News & commentary on sustainability, activism, urban planning, politics, and our world..

Inside The Box: People don’t actually like creativity

Created: 08 Dec 2013

Great article on Slate: In the United States we are raised to appreciate the accomplishments of inventors and

Reflection from Pakistani Participant

Created: 06 Dec 2013

Recently we hosted a group of Pakistani Visual Artists for a short workshop in Creative Activism (Read more ...

School for Creative Activism, a project of the Center for Artistic Activism — Social Text

Created: 22 Nov 2013

Overview The first rule of guerrilla warfare is to know the terrain and use it to your advantage.

Recipe to bust ads …

Created: 21 Nov 2013

German guerrilla street artists use simple recipes to cover fast food ads reminding onlookers that food cooked at ...

Crossed Legs Movement

Created: 31 Oct 2013

Colombian women are enacting a Lysistrata. The sex strike is being called the “crossed legs movement.”  Barbacaos’s sex

Narrative, comedy, and a message: The Internet Must Go

Created: 10 Sep 2013

In 2012, market researcher John Wooley was dispatched to help the big ISPs figure out how to sell

Annie Lennox on creativity: “leave the critic outside the room”

Created: 07 Sep 2013

  “Catch ideas… get them down… leave the critic outside the room, close the door, lock it really

IMAGINE there’s no fracking …

Created: 05 Sep 2013

“Don’t Frack My Mother” In addition to coming together through song/video to send a message to Governor Cuomo

Are you an overworked activist?

Created: 30 Aug 2013

“The enemy often tries to make us attempt and start many projects so that we will be overwhelmed ...

Border Patrol Body Slam

Created: 13 Aug 2013

In a California lucha libre-style wrestling match, Blue Demon Jr., a self-proclaimed defender of Mexican immigrants, does battle

Rights, Demands, and Radical Reimaginings: Art and Labor in the US

Created: 12 Aug 2013

Alexis Clements is running a class on Art and Labor. When: Tuesday evenings, from 7.00-8.30pm Aug 27 –

Egyptians Understand Spectacle

Created: 06 Jul 2013

Egypt: President Morsi defies army ultimatum. Now what? | Toronto Star.

David Letterman – Environmental Activist, Tim DeChristopher

Created: 30 Jun 2013

Tim DeChristopher makes an appearance on The Late Show with David Letterman and is able to talk about

Bloomberg’s Ramadan Breakfast menu

Created: 26 Jun 2013

Rumor has it that this special menu was distributed outside the Mayor of New York’s Ramadan breakfast celebration.

Wealth Inequality in America – YouTube

Created: 12 Jun 2013

Very encouraging that this video has 6.5 million views. Since our idea is so far from reality, how ...

Heavens, Not Havens

Created: 10 Jun 2013

Heavens, Not Havens A short article on the public relations problem around taxes and some ideas for helping ...

Make Your Own Damn Art – Bob and Roberta Smith – documentary trailer – YouTube

Created: 03 Jun 2013

Bob and Roberta Smith: ‘It’s important to undermine and subvert things’ Make Your Own Damn Art    

Freedom to Fail, Harvard-Style

Created: 01 May 2013

Even Harvard Business Review gets it: failure is a necessary part of creation and innovation.  This blog post ...

Tactics and Strategies

Created: 16 Apr 2013

A directory of tactics and strategies for human rights activism: http://www.newtactics.org/tactics

Escrache in Spain

Created: 16 Apr 2013

  The term “escrache” comes from Argentina, where it was coined in in 1995 by the human rights ...

Those in Charge

Created: 16 Apr 2013

On August 2012, seven black Mercedes drove through the Gran Vía, one of Madrid´s main streets. This image ...

Will changing your Facebook profile picture do anything for marriage equality? | PsySociety, Scientific American Blog Network

Created: 15 Apr 2013

As SCOTUS debates the constitutionality of Proposition 8 and DOMA this week, Facebook users all over the nation

Howitcouldbedifferent.org: A Wikipedia for Social Change

Created: 30 Mar 2013

  Looking for some inspiration for your next creative activist project? Look no further than howitcouldbedifferent.org, which is

33 Ways to Stay Creative

Created: 27 Mar 2013

Check out this list of 33 Ways to Stay Creative for small everyday suggestions on how to keep ...

From the Congo to Panama, Beat Making Labs Creates Sustainable Music Studios in Unlikely Places

Created: 25 Mar 2013

When most folks think of Africa, they automatically think of famine, disease, and war. But for those who understand

Comics in Kenya

Created: 22 Mar 2013

We’ve been in Kenya for the last week, and have been honored to work with talented activists from ...

Decaying Russian Buildings Transformed into Character Art

Created: 20 Mar 2013

Russian artist Nikita Nomerz art series,   “The Living Wall,” resurrects dilapidated buildings by turning them into pieces of art. In

Hip Hop for Healthy Eating

Created: 12 Mar 2013

Real Food Justice: From Black Panther Party Roots to Hip Hop Activism, Foodies with Fists   When his ...

Using Art to talk back to Unwanted “Compliments”

Created: 08 Mar 2013

  Shorty. Sweetie. Sweetheart. Baby. Boo. If you’re a woman, you’ve probably heard it. If you were to respond,

Crowdsourcing Change through Public Art

Created: 05 Mar 2013

  I Wish This Was began in New Orleans in November 2010. It was inspired by vacant storefronts. There

Grace and Gravity – Monumental Work by El Anatsui

Created: 25 Feb 2013

“In the exhibition are twelve recent monumental wall and floor sculptures, widely considered to represent the apex of

The Sounds of the Spanish Revolution

Created: 24 Feb 2013

After a demonstration, on May 15 2011, around forty people decided to sleep in Puerta del Sol, one ...

Creativetime 2012: How to disrupt the financial order with humor, creativity and a dash of mischief

Created: 24 Feb 2013

In Creativetime 2012, artist-activist Leónidas Martín from Enmedio Collective in Spain gives different guidelines on how make protest

Nonprofit Fights Poverty With Poverty | The Onion

Created: 22 Feb 2013

This is from 2006 but somehow stayed relevant. Our crack team of anti-poverty activists is totally devoted to

Pray the Devil Back to Hell

Created: 19 Feb 2013

Pray the Devil Back to Hell chronicles the remarkable story of the courageous Liberian women who came together to ...

Tedx Talk: “We are all born Artists”

Created: 19 Feb 2013

“There are so many reasons why we can’t be, indeed, we’re not sure why we should be. We ...

Use Art To Turn The World Inside Out

Created: 12 Feb 2013

“JR, a semi-anonymous French street artist, uses his camera to show the world its true face, by pasting

“The Kiss” in Syria Goes VIRAL

Created: 06 Feb 2013

Syrian artist Tammam Azzam took the twittersphere by storm last week when he posted an image of Gustav Klimt’s “The Kiss” superimposed on the

Event: Direct Action Fashion Show

Created: 04 Feb 2013

Join the Museum of Reclaimed Urban Space for the Direct Action Fashion Show Saturday, 02/09/2013 7:00pm 155 Ave ...

Creative Activism: The Art of Social Change

Created: 18 Jan 2013

  For our friends in Denmark! Steve Duncombe will be speaking and participating in an event called Creative

The Joker Always Wins

Created: 16 Jan 2013

One of my favorite lessons from the School for Creative Activism is this: fun can be powerful and ...

George Lakoff in 3 minutes

Created: 15 Jan 2013

Before anyone on the Left was talking about the importance of understanding the cognitive science of political decision ...

Laughing at Dictators

Created: 02 Jan 2013

From Good.is: The small former-Soviet republic Belarus is considered to be Europe’s last surviving dictatorship. Protestors and the

Rethinking the Protest Sign

Created: 02 Jan 2013

Our friends at the Overpass Light Brigade use LED lights for a new take on an old tool ...

“It Was a Good Day” Ice Cube and Politics

Created: 19 Dec 2012

“It Was a Good Day” is rapper Ice Cube’s biggest hit — a solid rap song with a

An Archive of Desire

Created: 10 Dec 2012

The name sounds vaguely like a catalog of clippings from the back of the Village Voice.  Fortunately it’s ...

Plastic Spoon Graphic

Created: 05 Dec 2012

I was reminded of this today (it was a viral hit a while back) and how it impacts ...

Behavioral Science in Campaigns

Created: 14 Nov 2012

This story in the New York Times talks about how behavioral science was used in the Obama campaign. ...

Show of Hands 2012 – bigger than ever

Created: 06 Nov 2012

School for Creative Activism alum, Donovan McKnight took the Show of Hands political party (literally, we mean party)

Richard Wolff on the economic crisis (2009)

Created: 04 Nov 2012

Economist, author, Professor emeritus UMass, Amherst, Richard Wolff, speaks about the current economic crises, its’ roots and what

On Evolution and Opiates

Created: 03 Nov 2012

Jerry Coyne explains why evolution is true. After all the scientific evidence it gets juicy. Coyne theorizes on ...

Failure Support Group – Saturday 11/3

Created: 02 Nov 2012

Failure Support Group Creative, social and activist projects fail. Sometimes miserably. Come share your failure with us in

L.M. Bogad

Created: 22 Oct 2012

Innovation, surprise… when you surprise someone, you’re earning a moment because you’re opening up a space. The surprise ...

An open letter to critics writing about political art

Created: 20 Oct 2012

Last weekend Creative Time held their fourth annual summit on the current state of artistic activism. Over two days, scores of political artists from around the world gave short presentations ...

John Hodgman “I LIKE WINNING”

Created: 01 Sep 2012

This morning at the Center for Artistic Activism we’re reading and talking about John Hodgman’s piece on 90

Mini-Documentary on Artist members of Iraq Veterans Against the War

Created: 10 Jul 2012

After discharge from service, integrating back into civilian society often comes with crisis. In Chicago, members of Iraq

ExtraEnvironmentalist Interview with CAA’s Steve Lambert

Created: 10 Jul 2012

The ExtraEnvironmentalist podcast recently did an interview with the Center for Artistic Activism’s Steve Lambert. With an educational

Mr. Rogers defends public funding to the US Senate and secures $20 Million

Created: 22 Jun 2012

Sincerity and ultimately a song win over a US Senator who has no idea who Mr. Rogers is.

“Look at him; no ribbons, no lace!” Cyrano teaches us old lessons

Created: 10 Jun 2012

I don’t think I understood how valuable this was in freshman year English class. What a strength to ...

Money is not Speech …

Created: 04 Jun 2012

… just one of the slogans to be used in a national campaign this summer. While stamp tactics ...

“Living in Limbo” brings LGBT issues to the Civil Rights Institute in Birmingham, Alabama

Created: 16 May 2012

Living in Limbo: A contemporary photography exhibit that honors the complexities of lesbian family life by revealing authentic

L.M. Bogad’s Economusic Performance

Created: 12 May 2012

Here’s a short excerpt of (CAA West Coast Director) Larry Bogad’s new Economusic which he performed on March

Dread Scott

Created: 10 Apr 2012

  “They denounced my work on the floor of the Senate as they passed the legislation. And President ...

The Pigs vs. The Freaks

Created: 04 Mar 2012

Will we see a Black Bloc vs. Riot Cops soccer match in 2012?

George Saunders talks about large impacts on small audiences

Created: 13 Feb 2012

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V3SpooNt3Ms

Joseph DeLappe

Created: 28 Jan 2012

“It may not effect change in the kind of physical sense that maybe we’ve been talking about, but ...

10 New Year’s resolutions for designers

Created: 03 Jan 2012

There’s some great chunks of wisdom in this .net magazine post from Mike Monteiro that we can creatively

Sarah Silverman, Comedy, and the idea of the meta-bigot

Created: 02 Jan 2012

This piece from Slate in 2005 introduces the interesting idea of a meta-bigots: Silverman has become an important

Party as a Political Act

Created: 22 Dec 2011

“We pulled off an event that invoked the shock of something completely different, but was also universally familiar, ...

An Occupied Halloween

Created: 14 Nov 2011

Big thanks to CAA’s friends Gan Golan and Mark Read for sending us these links to coverage of ...

Clowns Arrested in Near-Successful Attack on Wall Street Bull

Created: 14 Nov 2011

From the Yes Lab Earlier today, a small group of Occupy Wall Street activists engaged in a near-successful

APEC World Leaders Dinner Gets Occupied

Created: 14 Nov 2011

From the Yes Lab Honolulu – A change in the programmed entertainment at last night’s Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation

12,000 Encircle White House In Protest of Keystone XL Tar Sands Pipeline

Created: 06 Nov 2011

Today, more than 12,000 people from across the United States and Canada gathered at the White House to

Art and Subversive Humor

Created: 04 Nov 2011

The New York Times Magazine published an excellent article about artists and activists in China who evade censors ...

My Political Faith

Created: 05 Oct 2011

The following is a short piece I wrote for an on-line journal called freq.uenci.es who asked me to ...

Is This What Civil Disobedience Looks Like? — Nathan Schneider

Created: 03 Oct 2011

  Nathan Schneider, from Waging NonViolence makes an excellent point here in his coverage of the mass arrests

Will Bloomberg End Protesters’ Stay on Wall Street?

Created: 02 Oct 2011

New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg raised the specter of shutting down a two-week long demonstration on Wall

700 arrested at Occupy Wall Street

Created: 02 Oct 2011

Anjali Mullany/News A crowd of protesters and police officers swarmed the Brooklyn Bridge on Saturday. Thousands of Occupy

Moving Planet Rallies Prompt Global Climate Action

Created: 02 Oct 2011

More than 2,000 “Moving Planet” clean-energy demonstrations took place on Saturday, September 24th – at UN Headquarters in

Embodied

Created: 30 Sep 2011

On September 16th, fifty women wearing mini skirts and tank tops stood in the middle of a major ...

Hundreds gather to say no to Canada’s tar sands

Created: 27 Sep 2011

After 1,253 arrests in D.C. earlier this month against the proposed tar sands pipeline, hundreds gather in Canada

Trader’s Goldman Sachs comments spark BBC hoax claims

Created: 27 Sep 2011

Alessio Rastani, who claimed on BBC News ‘I dream of another recession’, is not a ‘Yes Man’ –

Tim DeChristopher speaks from prison

Created: 27 Sep 2011

Letter from prison: Tim DeChristopher speaks The following text appeared in a handwritten letter from Tim DeChristopher addressed

#OccupyWallStreet Bleeds and Leads

Created: 27 Sep 2011

Here is an interesting article from Waging Nonviolence about Occupy Wall Street. A bit after 10 p.m. on ...

The trouble with apocalypse

Created: 26 Sep 2011

The Post Carbon Institute published a thought provoking piece by Kurt Cobb on “apocalypse narratives.” We hear these

Serious Fun

Created: 26 Sep 2011

Tens of thousands of Chilean students resumed marches last week in Santiago, demanding a systemic overhaul of the ...

The CAA supports Beautiful Trouble. Will you?

Created: 23 Sep 2011

Beautiful Trouble will be a book & web toolbox that puts the best ideas and tactics of creative ...

People power: It’s the taking part that counts – The Independent

Created: 14 Aug 2011

The jailed Chinese dissident artist Ai Weiwei is part of a new cultural movement that’s using people power

8 Reasons Young Americans Don’t Fight Back

Created: 09 Aug 2011

Steve sent me this article in response to a question we were batting about around why there is ...

The greatest victory comes from culture, not weapons

Created: 03 Aug 2011

I’ve been reading Paul Provenza and Dan Dion’s ¡SATIRISTAS! Comedians, Contrarians, Raconteurs & Vulgarians and it’s filled with

Get Loud, Move Quickly, and Shifting Focus

Created: 30 Jul 2011

I love stuff like this because of the metaphors it supplies. I’m not a fighter. I haven’t been

Pie-ing Murdoch: Activism or Egoism?

Created: 19 Jul 2011

An “activist” just tried to pie Rupert Murdoch and The New York Times Blog put it very simply:

Man explains why he loves the Orlando Police Dept

Created: 10 Jul 2011

YouTube – ‪Shocking!! Man explains to WFTV News why he loves the Orlando Police Department – Hilarious!!‬‏.

Michael Albert argues for utopia

Created: 06 Jul 2011

Without using the word per se. Brilliant.

Can Conservative Political Humor Be Funny?

Created: 16 Jun 2011

“An Examination of The 1/2 Hour News Hour and An American Carol” on Splitsider today looks at why

Beyond The Choir:: Climate scientists reaching beyond the choir & dropping the F-bomb VIDEO

Created: 11 Jun 2011

reposted from BeyondTheChior A while back Chris Mooney, author of The Republican War on Science, offered some sound

The Importance of Stephen Colbert’s Bold and Subversive PAC

Created: 01 Jun 2011

Stephen Hoban has written a great summary and the full story is on Splitsider. Here’s the beginning: On

Poor Immigrant as Muse

Created: 19 May 2011

The following is an article about the artist Tania Bruguera and and her year-long project of living with ...

200 years ago The Luddites used humor, spectacle, narrative, and myth

Created: 06 May 2011

From The Right To Be Lazy. Ned Ludd was a fictitious leader. Costumes, jokes, and more. Here’s an

Overcoming political polarization… but not through facts

Created: 01 May 2011

Ethan Zuckerman has posted a beautiful piece that stitches together many of the ideas we deal with in

Diggers: If you can act it out, it’s real.

Created: 23 Apr 2011

We thought: culture is much more important than politics. Let’s just start getting people living the way they

New ‘Tactical Urbanism’ guide for aspiring guerrilla urbanists | Grist

Created: 09 Apr 2011

The Next Generation of New Urbanists yes, these are young New Urbanists, because New Urbanism has been around

Culture Gap – New York Bike Lanes

Created: 22 Mar 2011

Duncombe and I have said more than once “you can change the laws, but it won’t matter if ...

Design with Intent Toolkit

Created: 27 Jan 2011

Design with Intent:101 Patterns for Influencing Behaviour Through Design All design influences our behaviour, but as designers we

Creative militancy meets militant creativity

Created: 28 Dec 2010

By Sarah Amsler Lecturer in Sociology at Aston University (Birmingham, UK) via the Huffington Post Under what might

In Kansas, Climate Skeptics Embrace Green Energy – NYTimes.com

Created: 11 Dec 2010

Attempts by the Obama administration to regulate greenhouse gases are highly unpopular here because of opposition to large-scale

Arnold Schwarzenegger knows environmental leadership

Created: 19 Nov 2010

“I think that I have the talent of speaking the language in such a way so that the

Imagine Peace by Yoko Ono

Created: 04 Jul 2010

IMAGINE PEACE by yoko ono to the pebble people: start your own campaign! A butterfly is hopping from ...

BJ Fogg’s Behavior Model

Created: 19 May 2010

What Causes Behavior Change? My Behavior Model shows that three elements must converge at the same moment for ...

What is Winning? Results. – Indymedia Ireland

Created: 15 May 2010

Via Indymedia Ireland Activist Questionnaire Results This is an attempt at a summary of the results of questionnaires,

Charting Creativity: Neurologically

Created: 08 May 2010

Charting Creativity: Signposts of a Hazy Territory NY Times, Patricia Cohen, May 7, 2010 Grab a timer and ...

About Culture Push

Created: 19 Apr 2010

Culture Push is about hands-on learning, group problem solving, serious play and creating connections. The mission of Culture ...

Carol Tavris – Mistakes Were Made

Created: 05 Apr 2010

Audio Interview at Carol Tavris – Mistakes Were Made | For Good Reason. Carol Tavris describes dissonance theory

Hip-Hop Word Count™

Created: 17 Mar 2010

Hiop-Hop Word Count by Tahir Hemphill: We have developed a rubric that estimates the education level needed to ...

Provisions Library Blog

Created: 18 Feb 2010

Signal Fire is the blog of Provisions Library, a non-profit learning resource for arts and social change. Provisions

Al Gore on Creative Activism

Created: 14 Jan 2010

Click to play or download here: Al Gore On Creative Activism.

A promise not satisfied

Created: 04 Jan 2010

“Aesthetic art promises a political accomplishment that it cannot satisfy, and thrives on that ambiguity. That is why

badpaintingsofbarackobama.com

Created: 19 Dec 2009

just look at it: badpaintingsofbarackobama.com.

Again, the truth doesn't matter

Created: 19 Dec 2009

A smart lefty is frustrated that the right is getting ahead by asserting lies and the left sticks ...

Underwear Gnomes

Created: 16 Dec 2009

Someone mentioned this to me. This still frame is from an episode of South Park where gnomes are ...

New Anti-Smoking Ads Warn Teens 'It's Gay To Smoke'

Created: 07 Dec 2009

New Anti-Smoking Ads Warn Teens ‘It’s Gay To Smoke’

Excerpt from: The Culture Crash by James Panero

Created: 02 Dec 2009

While the argument Singer is making here is about philanthropy, one could extend that to any effort made

Eve Mosher

Created: 11 Nov 2009

[private]Themes: Provoking intimate conversations and delivering more info. Pyramid scheme. Awakening as a political artist. Quantifiable metrics of

Bottle Bank Arcade

Created: 10 Nov 2009

OK, it’s essentially an off-beat ad campaign by Volkswagon, but it does say something about modeling social behavior ...

Test Marketing Michael Moore

Created: 23 Sep 2009

NY Times article (9/20/09) on Michael Moore and how he tests the effect of his movies: “Although I’m ...

Miami's Community Avengers

Created: 11 Sep 2009

Have No Fear the Community Avengers are Here! As the right wing mob mobilizes to shut down democratic ...

Where's Conservative Art? Crunchy Con

Created: 02 Sep 2009

Asking our question (kind of) from the other side of the aisle. See especially the comments section. Where’s

In Response (from naylandblake.net)

Created: 09 Aug 2009

A friend wrote me a letter and after thinking about it for a while I decided that I ...

SFMOMA | OPEN SPACE » No More Posters! Let’s See Action!

Created: 31 Jul 2009

My specific point here is that it’s time for activist design to go further than simple commentary. Not

Politcal Communications Strategy

Created: 30 Jul 2009

Interesting blog piece from the Huffington Post from a political communications strategist about How To Win: Ill Communication:

Politics of Surrealism

Created: 13 Jul 2009

Some interesting tidbits from The Politics of Surrealism by Helena Lewis (NY: Paragon House, 1988) “[Surrealism] tried to

Art and Revolution – The MIT Press

Created: 09 Jul 2009

As hopeful as it is incisive, Art and Revolution encourages a new generation of artists and thinkers to ...

Anti-Smoking Ads: pain, suffering and dismemberment works.

Created: 08 Jul 2009

Anti-smoking ads historically highlight one blunt fact: smoking kills. But the World Lung Foundation has analyzed the effectiveness

Is "professionalization" in art equal to success?

Created: 21 Jun 2009

I caught a link on We Make Money Not Art to this Artworld Salon article that contemplated the

James Balog, art and journalism

Created: 05 Apr 2009

Listening to James Balog I realized there is another point on our spectrum; journalism.  At another point is

From howtowin.org:

Created: 11 Mar 2009

howtowin

"Entertainment- Education and Social Change"

Created: 09 Mar 2009

“Entertainment- Education and Social Change” M.J. Papa, et al, Journal of Communication, 50, 2000, pp. 31-55 This seems ...

Do It!

Created: 09 Mar 2009

[audio:http://howtowin.visitsteve.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/01-do-it-1.mp3] The Pink Fairies – Do It (1971) Listen to this song and you can’t help but be

The Efficacy of Soap Operas

Created: 05 Mar 2009

“Increase in Calls to the CDC National STD and AIDS Hotline Following AIDS-Related Episodes in a Soap Opera”

“But Does it Work?” discussion at Elizabeth Foundation

Created: 23 Feb 2009

But Does it Work? Art, Activism and the Interventionist’s Gesture Tuesday, February 24, 6:30 pm A Conversation between

On The Media: The Science of Media Relations

Created: 20 Feb 2009

Being a brilliant scientist doesn’t always translate into being a good talking head on television or even a

Jonah Lehrer on Colbert

Created: 15 Feb 2009

The Colbert ReportMon – Thurs 11:30pm / 10:30c Jonah Lehrer Emotions vs. Rationality in decision making. Artists need

Environmental Facts

Created: 03 Feb 2009

I have been working with a general assumption that most people, in 2008/9, understand that there is a ...

There is no "win"

Created: 23 Jan 2009

Ok, I am kinda lovin’ Jay Smooth right now. Success means that we move further towards the ideals. ...

The power of the symbolic win (do-over)

Created: 23 Jan 2009

apparently I added the wrong video the last time I tried to do this, so let me try ...

Michael Israel inspires change!

Created: 23 Jan 2009

(check 1:30 in) See, what happens is, you see this, and then you go home and you decide ...

Art Hoax Unites Europe in Displeasure

Created: 15 Jan 2009

This is a beautiful example of how activist-pranksters can exploit bureaucracy’s Achilles heel. The artist commissioned for this

"Oblique Strategies": Brian Eno and Peter Schmidt's "How to Win" card game

Created: 11 Jan 2009

  Brian Eno, the father of ambient music and Peter Schmidt, an English artist, created this deck of

Jacques Ranciere on political art

Created: 10 Jan 2009

[A]n aesthetic politics always defines itself by a certain recasting of the distribution of the sensible, a reconfiguration

Utah Student Wrecks Federal Land Auction

Created: 02 Jan 2009

This guy is great. He saw an opportunity and jumped on it, disrupting a corrupt auction, costing major ...

Marketing Lessons from Obama's Campaign – BusinessWeek

Created: 26 Nov 2008

In recent weeks, I’ve ended up more than once amid marketing executives discussing, with apparent seriousness, what the

Oh Yes They Did! – artnet Magazine

Created: 21 Nov 2008

My take is a little different. If anything, I think activists are already excessively focused on the media. ...

Mark Fiore's Subversive Cartoons

Created: 28 Oct 2008

Mark Fiore is a political Flash cartoonist who cranks out a new short almost every week. He is ...

LIVERMORE / Anti-nuke activists lose out on bid to run weapons lab

Created: 26 Oct 2008

A bid by Bay Area anti-nuclear weapons activists and the New College of California to take over Lawrence

Wassup 2008

Created: 25 Oct 2008

Funny, engaged in pop culture, arguably hard-hitting message… this is good.

Laugh at a Campaign Pitch? Sure. Visit the Grandparents? Not So Much. – NYTimes.com

Created: 23 Oct 2008

MIAMI — When Sarah Silverman told young Jews to get their lazy rotund rear ends to Florida to

Larry Flynt Producing 'Palin porno' political parody

Created: 14 Oct 2008

I think the key line here actually comes at the end. “Whatever you think of Larry Flynt, the

Aaron Gach / The Center for Tactical Magic

Created: 26 Sep 2008

Aaron Gach is the founder of the Center for Tactical Magic and has a notable background. As part ...

Design Won't Save The World

Created: 08 Sep 2008

Yimmys Yayo

The Penguin "gets it"

Created: 07 Sep 2008

YouTube – Pol-d

Seun Kuti

Created: 04 Sep 2008

Seun Kuti was interviewed on PRI’s Sound of Young America a couple weeks ago. Choice excerpt typed below ...

I’m Rubber, You’re Glue …

Created: 28 Aug 2008

by Jonathan Alter Published Aug 23, 2008 From Newsweek magazine issue dated Sep 1, 2008 It’s hard to ...

GRL's James Powderly detained in Beijing for planning pro-Tibet

Created: 19 Aug 2008

“James is a unique voice in the world, who lives and breathes art and technology for the purpose

The State: Free Market Store

Created: 18 Aug 2008

For those not fortunate enough to remember watching The State, it was a brilliant comedy show often surreal ...

Tropic Thunder – comedy is anarchy

Created: 13 Aug 2008

…in comedy, context is everything. “Tropic Thunder”… doesn’t risk simply offending; at times the picture is almost appalling

I met the Walrus

Created: 13 Aug 2008

In 1970, a fourteen year old boy named Jerry Levitan snuck into John Lennon and Yoko Ono’s Montreal ...

Natalie Jeremijenko

Created: 12 Aug 2008

YouTube – Interview: Feedback Artist, Natalie Jeremijenko Also in the NYT today: “People are frustrated by their inability

Get Your War On: Terrorist Watch List

Created: 03 Aug 2008

This is a new video from 23/6.com a political-ish comedy site. The video is about a serious issue, ...

Kurt Vonnegut Interview Mashup

Created: 01 Aug 2008

I read Timequake (one of Vonnegut’s last books) recently and was surprised to see how often it related ...

Artists are Now Taking the Lead the Politicians Have Failed to Give (2007)

Created: 20 Jul 2008

Madeleine Bunting “Artists are Now Taking the Lead the Politicians Have Failed to Give” The Live Art Almanac

Letter from Oaxaca (2006)

Created: 20 Jul 2008

Guilermo Gómez-Peña “Letter from Oaxaca: Performing the Flames” The Live Art Almanac Live Art UK, 2008 pp. 47-50

“Proximity to Politics” 3 Book Review

Created: 16 Jul 2008

via: Miscellaneous Projects Originally Written for Boot Print Volume #2 (St. Louis, USA) Proximity to Politics: A Review

The Changing Face of the U.S. Consumer

Created: 13 Jul 2008

via: Ad Age NEW YORK (AdAge.com) — The marketing community, already dealing with a slumping economy and an

The first challenge of climate crisis is…

Created: 11 Jul 2008

The most fundamental reality at the present time is that the human species has over shot the capacity

Art and Propaganda (1924)

Created: 02 Jul 2008

William Pickens (1924) Art and Propaganda Extract from The Messenger, New York, April 1924 (reprinted in Art and ...

Programme Declaration (1919)

Created: 02 Jul 2008

Komfut (1919) Programme Declaration Iskusstvo Kommuny (Art of the Commune) No. 8, Petrograd, 26 January 1919 (reprinted in ...

San Francisco to vote on naming sewer after George Bush

Created: 29 Jun 2008

Is this art? Is it activistm? Certainly, the power elite are not shaking in their boots over such

Game Culture

Created: 26 Jun 2008

Play is one of the earliest and most important activities of mammals; helping adolescents learn the skills they ...

Quote from Georg Baselitz

Created: 26 Jun 2008

This mythology of the lone genius, isolated from society, and relieved of social responsibility, is summed up for ...

How to Win! An Introduction…

Created: 25 Jun 2008

“How to Win” is a work in progress by Stephen Duncombe, an academic, and Steve Lambert, an artist. We are both long-time political activists and both of us believe that using art and culture to ...

En Avant Dada: A History of Dadaism(1920)

Created: 25 Jun 2008

Richard Huelsenbeck (1920) En Avant Dada: A History of Dadaism From En Avant Dada: Eine Geschichte des Dadaismus, ...

Architect Lebbeus Woods

Created: 23 Jun 2008

In all honesty I don’t know Woods’ work well. Just finished this interview and he has a reputation ...

How George Carlin Changed Comedy

Created: 23 Jun 2008

via: Time When the culture began to change in the late 1960s — when the old one-liner comics ...

Photographer Documents Secret Satellites — All 189 of Them

Created: 23 Jun 2008

BERKELEY, California — For most people, photographing something that isn’t there might be tough. Not so for Trevor

John Pilger – Freedom Next Time

Created: 19 Jun 2008

This is great speech by journalist John Pilger on the powers and dangers of corporate media. I think ...

The New York Times: Street Maps in Political Hues

Created: 16 Jun 2008

This is an old Eyebeam R&D Project.  If you haven’t used Fundrace, try it out.  There’s something amazing

PRWatch: Corporate Sponsored Slacktivism

Created: 15 Jun 2008

After reading this, I wonder if artists or activists have been unwittingly influenced/inspired by some of these token,

good answer to a relevant question by some guy

Created: 30 Apr 2008

Q: Of the various projects the Anti-Advertising Agency has been involved in, which ones do you think have

Web Analytics

Created: 29 Apr 2008

Web analytics allow you to track how many people are visiting your site, what sites they are coming ...

Loss Aversion, Greenpeace, and Health

Created: 29 Apr 2008

Here’s a pattern of tactics I realized have something in common. They all work by presenting a threat.

Hans Haacke

Created: 21 Apr 2008

Hans Haacke lecture Gallatin School, New York University, April 15, 2008 S&S: As a political artist, how can ...

But Is It Politics?

Created: 13 Apr 2008

Bad art makes bad political art....To those who would charge that thinking through the efficacy of political art turns art into propaganda I would say: absolutely. But sublime, and successful, ...

Future Farmers: ~Human Knot~

Created: 06 Apr 2008

One month after the United States invaded Iraq, Futurefarmers put out a public call for people to come ...

NYT – April Fool! The Purpose of Pranks

Created: 06 Apr 2008

By BENEDICT CAREY Published: April 1, 2008 Keep it above the belt, stop short of total humiliation and,